Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island

Egg sandwiches make great breakfasts or lunches, especially for those on the go (and that’s pretty much every working person on Long Island). They’re simple yet delicious, and they can be made in a variety of different ways. On an english muffin, a roll or croissant; with pepper and ketchup or cheese and sausage. The possibilities are (almost) endless. So the next time you want to sink your teeth into this soft, delicious egg-y meal, try the Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island.

2024: Long Island Voted Hilltop Bagel Café Best Egg Sandwich!

Hilltop Bagel Café
623 Horseblock Rd, Farmingville
(631) 846-1828 – hilltopbagelcafe.com

Indulge your egg sandwich cravings at Hilltop Bagel Cafe, the ultimate destination for your next delightful fix. Located in Farmingville, this beloved eatery boasts a diverse breakfast menu, enticing weekly specials, and convenient catering services. Beyond its reputation as a community staple, Hilltop Bagel Cafe takes pride in offering a variety of wraps, sandwiches, salads, and delectable desserts. Renowned for its luscious cream cheeses and refreshing Italian ices, the cafe’s true star is the egg sandwich—a standout among its scrumptious offerings. For a comprehensive look at all that Hilltop Bagel Cafe has to offer, including a full range of menu items and services, explore their website today.

2023: Long Islanders Voted Hilltop Bagel Cafe Best Egg Sandwich!

Hilltop Bagel Cafe
623 Horseblock Rd, Farmingville
(631) 846-1828 – hilltopbagelcafe.com

If you’re craving an egg sandwich, then Hilltop Bagel Cafe is your go-to spot for your next fix. Hilltop Bagel Cafe is a Farmingville-based eatery that has a robust breakfast menu, weekly specials, and catering services. Hilltop Bagel Cafe is a beloved staple of the community that also offers wraps, sandwiches, salads, and desserts; the cafe is especially famed for its cream cheeses and Italian ices. Yet amid all of those scrumptious offerings, the egg sandwich truly stands out. To learn more or see a full range of Hilltop Bagel Cafe’s offerings and services, visit its website.

2022: Long Islanders Voted Druthers Coffee Best Egg Sandwich!

Druthers Coffee
1113 North Country Rd, Building 5, Stony Brook
631-364-9667 – www.druthers.coffee

The Druthers Egg Sandwich is a staple item at this Stony Brook coffee shop. Launching the food menu in 2020, Druthers Coffee was particularly proud of their egg sandwich. The eggs, locally produced from Raleighs Poultry Farm, are topped with smoked cheddar, crispy shallots, and Calabrian chili aioli. All this deliciousness is placed on an everything bagel from Black Seed Bagels in Brooklyn. Regulars have called the Druthers Egg Sandwich “crazy good” and “the best egg sandwich you can find on Long Island.”

2021: Long Islanders Voted Tamburino’s Deli Best Egg Sandwich!

Tamburino’s Deli
672 Central Ave, Cedarhurst
(516) 295-2769 – facebook.com/Tamburinos-Italian-American-Deli-Inc

Sometimes, you need a “wake up” breakfast sandwich to get you through the morning. At Tamburino’s Deli in Cedarhurst, there’s no better option than its mouthwatering egg sandwiches that’ll satisfy you through lunch and beyond. Its egg sandwiches are served over hard and covered with perfectly toasted bread. For a true New York-style egg sandwich, you can order it with bacon and melted cheese. Whatever your choice, the staff at Tamburino’s Deli are committed to making the best egg sandwiches on Long Island that’ll have you planning your next trip to the Five Towns!

2020: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop Best Egg Sandwich!

CJ’s Coffee Shop
225 N Long Beach Rd, Rockville Centre
(516) 766-9107 – cjscoffeeshop.com

Long Islanders know that egg sandwiches are the perfect way to start the day and CJ’s Coffee Shop recognizes the demand for a fantastic breakfast sandwich. From the classic bacon, egg and cheese sandwich to the more hearty potato and egg cheese sandwich – all presented on a fresh roll, CJ’s has been serving up some of the most unique and delicious combos in Rockville Centre since 1979! CJ’s has also cemented its status as the top egg sandwich spot in Long Island for the better part of a decade.

2019: Long Islanders Voted Jeco’s Deli Best Egg Sandwich!

Jeco’s Deli
217 Smithtown Blvd., Nesconset
(631) 361-7101 – facebook.com/Jecos-Deli-Catering

A delicious egg sandwich can be an excellent way to start your day. There’s no better place to go for an egg sandwich than Jeco’s Deli, located conveniently in Nesconset. They featuring all of the best meats and other deli products served by an excellent, helpful staff. Jeco’s Deli also provides catering services for that special occasion you and your family wish to celebrate. There’s nothing like a locally owned deli with a great egg sandwich, which Jeco’s truly prides themselves in. Truly a must-experience, New York kind of meal. You’ll get in and out and be satisfied with your order no matter what. Jeco’s Deli provides everything you want in your delicatessen experience and nothing you and your family don’t. They truly value their customers.

2018: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island

CJ’s Coffee Shop 225 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre 516-766-9107 cjscoffeeshop.com

Scrambled, fried or perhaps even over-easy, C.J.’s Coffee Shop makes a mean egg sandwich that has been praised by Long Islanders throughout both counties and the region. Bacon, can I get some bacon and sausage on there? Cheese? Ketchup!? Of course! No matter how you prefer this morning staple, C.J.’s ensures it’s absolutely perfect, each and every time!

2017: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island

CJ’s Coffee Shop
225 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-9107. cjscoffeeshop.com
Scrambled, fried or perhaps even over-easy, C.J.’s Coffee Shop makes a mean egg sandwich that has been praised by Long Islanders throughout both counties and the region. Bacon, can I get some bacon and sausage on there? Cheese? Ketchup!? Of course! No matter how you prefer this morning staple, C.J.’s ensures it’s absolutely perfect, each and every time!

2016: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island

CJ’s Coffee Shop
225 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-9107. cjscoffeeshop.com
Scrambled, fried or perhaps even over-easy, CJ’s Coffee Shop makes a mean egg sandwich that has been praised by Long Islanders throughout both counties and the region. Bacon, can I get some bacon and sausage on there? Cheese? Ketchup!? Of course! No matter how you prefer this morning staple, CJ’s ensures it’s absolutely perfect, each and every time!

2015: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island!

CJ’s Coffee Shop
225 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-9107. cjscoffeeshop.com
New Yorkers are serious about their egg sandwiches, so you know to win best in this contest they must have a Golden Goose laying those eggs. Scrambled, fried, with bacon or without—but always with cheese—this quaint downtown eatery is the place to go when the eggwich crave strikes!

2014: Long Islanders Voted C.J.’s Coffee Shop in Rockville Centre Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island!

1. C.J.’s Coffee Shop
225 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-9107.

2. Avenue Delicatessen
290 Hempstead Ave., West Hempstead. 516-493-9555. avenuedelicaterers.com

3. Jeco’s Deli & Catering
217 Smithtown Blvd., Nesconset. 631-361-7101.

2013: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop in Rockville Centre Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island!

1. CJ’s Coffee Shop
225 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-9107. www.cjscoffeeshop.com

2. Jeco’s Deli & Catering
217 Smithtown Blvd., Nesconset. 631-361-7101

3. Bagel Boss
Multiple Locations. www.bagelboss.com

2012: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop in Rockville Centre Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island!

1. CJs Coffee Shop
225 Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-9107.

2. Bagel Boss
Multiple Locations. www.bagelboss.com

3. Crave Deli & Catering
395 Merrick Ave., Merrick. 516-379-1135. cravemerrick.wordpress.com

2011: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island!

1. Bagel Boss
Multiple locations. www.bagelboss.com

2. CJ’s Coffee Shop
225 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-9107

3. A Taste of Home
1992 N. Jerusalem Rd., North Bellmore. 516-486-1670. www.atasteofhomebakery.com

2010: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss The Best Egg Sandwich On Long Island!