Crispy on the outside, warm and melty on the inside—there’s nothing quite like a well-made panini. Whether stuffed with classic Italian meats and cheeses, fresh veggies, or creative flavor combinations, a panini turns an ordinary sandwich into something extraordinary. Long Island is home to countless delis and cafés serving up this toasted delight. If you’re craving the perfect panini, check out who our readers have voted as the Best Panini on Long Island.
2026: Long Islanders Voted Salad-icious Best Panini!
Salad-icious
83 East Main St, Smithtown
(646) 265-7618 – salad-icious.com
Salad-icious in Smithtown is a family-owned destination for fresh, made-to-order meals that go well beyond salads, including chef-crafted panini and wraps. Founded by locals Mike and Kristi in 2022, the menu emphasizes high-quality, wholesome ingredients and more than 15 preservative-free dressings that complement their diverse offerings. Guests can build their own creations or choose from signature options like the Avo BLT, Kale Chicken Caesar wrap, and Veggie wrap, all of which can be grilled or pressed to perfection. While known for its salads and bowls, Salad-icious also serves panini-style pressed wraps with a variety of fillings on choice of white, whole wheat, or gluten-free wraps, combining crisp, fresh produce with proteins like roasted chicken, bacon, and vegan options for a satisfying and balanced meal.
2025: Long Islanders Voted Press 195 Best Panini!
Press 195
22 N Park Avenue, Rockville Centre
(516) 536-1950 – press195.com
Press 195 in Rockville Centre has delighted patrons with its exceptional paninis since opening its doors in late 2010. Known for their homemade ciabatta bread, baked fresh daily, and a menu featuring over 40 creative sandwich combinations, they’ve mastered the art of the perfect panini. Enjoy their classic hot press heroes or bold flavor combinations like buffalo chicken or caprese paninis with fresh mozzarella. Their commitment to quality and flavor has earned them a reputation as a must-visit spot for panini enthusiasts on Long Island. Press 195 also offers an impressive selection of craft beers, salads and small plates, making it a versatile dining destination. With a commitment to fresh ingredients and exceptional flavor, Press 195 has become a culinary gem in Rockville Centre.