Like burgers, hot dogs are a staple at barbecues on Long Island in the summer. They’re also a must-have at Long Island Ducks games. Nestled in a soft toasted bun and topped with chili and cheese, sauerkraut or just plain ketchup and mustard, one dog usually isn’t enough. But no matter what season it is, if your tastebuds are craving a frankfurter, then look no further than the place with the Best Hot Dogs on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs Best Hot Dogs!
Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs
16 Lowell Ave, Islip terrace
(631) 627-3480
The beloved franks served at Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs are a Long Island favorite. Locals line up for their favorite toppings, though there’s no debating that Charlie’s onion sauce is truly “legendary.” Luckily, you can take home a jar when you order your dogs. Started in 1963 by a disabled veteran of World War II, Charlie’s remains a family-owned business. When the beloved Brentwood stand briefly closed, fans of Charlie’s clamored for its revival. Fortunately, they got their wish, so you can enjoy a Charlie’s hot dog with chili, cheese, or, yes, the famous onion sauce at their Islip Terrance location.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Chubs Burgers Burritos and Heroes Best Hot Dogs!
Chubs Burgers Burritos and Heroes
625 Horseblock Rd, Farmingville
(631) 880-7999 – chubsbbh.com
When you think of a hot dog, you probably think of baseball games, Times Square food carts, and quick dinners. But this humble classic takes a quality spin at Chubs Burgers Burritos and Heroes. Ryan Jones’ butchery background shines through this menu item as he elevates it with quality meats and clever toppings, such as mac ‘n’ cheese and hot Cheetos. If you couldn’t tell already, Jones is an innovator, so don’t expect your average mustard and ketchup combo. Flavor combinations vary from items like The Messier Dog topped with sour kraut, onions, and mustard to The Pirate Hot Dog packed with coleslaw, queso, and ranch. All dogs are just $4.99 or can be made a meal for $13.99, which includes two dogs, fries, and a deli iced tea or lemonade. Jones is putting hot dog stands to shame with quality ingredients and fair prices.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Nathan’s Famous, Inc. Best Hot Dogs! (National)
Nathan’s Famous, Inc.
Multiple Locations
nathansfamous.com
Nathan’s Famous, Inc. is an All-American fast food brand that needs no introduction. The original Nathan’s restaurant is still located in Coney Island. Nathan’s Famous eateries have since expanded out to venues all over America, and their hot dogs are especially beloved by Long Islanders. Nathan’s Famous is especially well known for its Hot Dog Eating contest that is held every Fourth of July at the Brooklyn location and attended by approximately 35,000 fans; millions more watch the ESPN telecast of the contest. World Champion Joey Chestnut currently holds the title of hot dog-eating world champion after setting a new world record of 76 hot dogs and buns in 2021.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Knot of This World Pretzels Best Hot Dogs!
Knot of This World Pretzels
3041 Hempstead Tpke, Levittown
(516) 238-0382 – knotofthisworldpretzels.com
Addicted to hot dogs in pretzels? You might be at this pretzel store where one bite into the dog stuffed in doughy deliciousness will change your world. Expect to sink your teeth into a fresh, giant, and snap-happy frankfurter. The sensationally delicious soft baked dough shaped in a symmetrical loop is a cozy bun alternative and a real treat here. Considered perfectly sized for sharing and worth every penny, the pretzel part is not too salty or dense, just light, very fresh, and too tempting with the frank inside to carry out and eat later … you’ll gobble the combo up on the spot! Some even say they’re out of this world. Try dipping one in honey mustard and you’ll be hooked. Find out for yourself. It’s about time you found out what a real New York pretzel and hot dog tastes like at Knot of This World!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Nathan’s Famous, Inc. Best Hot Dogs!
Nathan’s Famous, Inc.
Multiple Locations
nathansfamous.com
There’s a reason why Nathan’s Famous has the best hot dogs in town. Since 1916, Nathan’s has been serving up its classic hot dogs, causing hungry Long Islanders to flock to their shops for a quick bite to eat. While the eatery started off with your standard hot dog, Nathan’s has since stepped up its game and added chili and cheese into the mix, making it the ultimate lunch or dinner for the Long Islander on the go. While the menu has expanded to include burgers and chicken as well, nothing beats a Nathan’s hot dog — there’s a reason why the eatery’s hot dog has stood the test of time.
2020: Long Islanders Voted Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs the Best Hot Dogs!
Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs
16 Lowell Ave, Islip Terrace
(631) 617-3480 – charlieslegendaryonions.com
Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs has a fantastic story that could only happen on Long Island. Many years ago, a man named Charles Summa, a disabled WWII Veteran, was in search for a way to provide for his family. In 1963, he and his wife Rosemary decided to open a hot dog stand located in Brentwood, Long Island, NY. What started as a small pushcart quickly grew into the Famous Charlie’s Hot Dogs, serving many generations of Long Islanders for over 55 years. Charlie’s Legendary Onions were a marvel hit, and remains his biggest success to date. The family has not only revived Charlie’s recipe, but has also introduced Charlie’s Hot Dog Truck and they are ready to share it with the world once again!
Nathan’s Famous, Inc. (National Winner)
Multiple Locations
nathansfamous.com
Founded on Coney Island and headquartered in Jericho, Nathan’s Famous, Inc. lives up to its name by making the best hot dog in New York. It all began with a Polish immigrant and his wife’s secret spice recipe. Over a century later, Nathan’s is synonymous with good hot dogs–and good times eating them with your favorite condiments! You’ll find these famous franks in supermarkets and on the menu at Nathan’s restaurants all over Long Island. Famously, you’ll see them gobbled by the dozen at the annual hot-dog eating contest on Coney Island every Fourth of July. No matter how quickly you eat them, you’ll enjoy every bite of a Nathan’s hot dog.
2019: Long Islanders Voted Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs the Best Hot Dogs!
Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs
16 Lowell Ave., Islip terrace
(631) 617-3480 – www.charlieslegendaryonions.com
Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs has a fantastic story that could only happen on Long Island. Many years ago, a man named Charles Summa, a disabled WWII Veteran was in search for a way to provide for his family. In 1963, he and his wife Rosemary decided to open a hot dog stand located in Brentwood, Long Island, NY. What started as a small pushcart quickly grew into the Famous Charlie’s Hot Dogs, serving many generations of Long Islanders for over 50 years. Charlie’s Legendary Onions were a marvel hit, his biggest success to date. The family has not only revived Charlie’s recipe, but Charlie’s Hot Dog Truck, ready to share it with the world once again! The world will love these great tasting hot dogs.
Nathan’s Famous, Inc. (National Winner)
Multiple Locations
www.nathansfamous.com
Founded on Coney Island and headquarted in Jericho, Nathan’s Famous lives up to its name by making the best hot dog in New York. It all began with a Polish immigrant and his wife’s secret spice recipe. Now, 102 years later, Nathan’s is synonymous with good hot dogs–and good times eating them with your favorite condiments! You’ll find these famous franks in supermarkets and on the menu at Nathan’s restaurants all over Long Island. Famously, you’ll see them gobbled by the dozen at the annual hot-dog eating contest on Coney Island every Fourth of July. No matter how quickly you eat them, you’ll enjoy every bite of a Nathan’s hot dog.
2018: Long Islanders Voted Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs the Best on Long Island!
Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs
16 Lowell Avenue
Islip Terrace, N.Y. 11752
(631) 617-3480 – charlieslegendaryonions.com
The beloved franks served at Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs are a Long Island favorite. Locals line up for their favorite toppings, though there’s no debating that Charlie’s onion sauce is truly “legendary.” Luckily, you can take home a jar when you order your dogs. Started in 1963 by a disabled veteran of World War II, Charlie’s remains a family-owned business. When the beloved Brentwood stand briefly closed, fans of Charlie’s clamored for its revival. Fortunately, they got their wish, so you can enjoy a Charlie’s hot dog with chili, cheese, or, yes, the famous onion sauce at their Islip Terrance location.
2017: Long Islanders Voted Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Restaurant & Caterers Best Hot Dogs on Long Island
Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Restaurant & Caterers Multiple Locations. 1-800-344-BENS. bensdeli.net Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Restaurant & Caterers doesn’t just have the Best Dinner Deals on Long Island—it has the Best Hot Dogs as well. For the third year in a row, Ben’s has been named the best place to get a hot dog on Long Island! Whether you like your hot dog covered in sauerkraut, slathered with mustard or piled high with onions, Ben’s is the go-to spot. And with extraordinary customer service, any other hot dog simply doesn’t stand a chance against this Long Island staple! National Winner: Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Multiple Locations. nathansfamous.com Nathan’s Famous has been a hot spot for people who love to chow down on flavorful, tasty hot dogs since its opening more than 100 years ago in 1916, right here on the East Coast, in Coney Island. They’re just something special about biting into a Nathan’s hot dog! It’s no wonder why Long Islanders consistently vote Nathan’s the absolute best!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Ben’s Kosher Delicatessan Best Hot Dogs on Long Island
Ben’s Kosher Delicatessan Multiple Locations. bensdeli.net Thick, juicy, meaty and filling, Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen’s hot dogs are music to the taste buds and bellies of all who’ve enjoyed their euphoric girth. Slathered in mustard, topped with a healthy mound of sauerkraut, or coated with any number of Ben’s fantastic sides, these franks are sheer perfection squeezed between a super-soft, warm bun. Pair them up with any number of Ben’s delicious dishes or go solo—you simply can’t go wrong with one (or three) of these! National Winner: Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Multiple Locations. nathansfamous.com Nathan’s knows hot dogs. Since their first batch at Coney Island in 1916 to their plump, juicy of frankfurters at any of their locations across Long Island and beyond, Nathan’s dogs have become renowned worldwide for their oh-so-special goodness. Load them up with ketchup, mustard, some pickles and maybe some sauerkraut–Long Islanders have voted yet again that Nathan’s hot dogs are The Best!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Best Hot Dogs on Long Island!
Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Multiple Locations. bensdeli.net To sink your incisors into a steaming, fully loaded “Hebrew National big fat quarter-pound kosher frank,” as they appear on Ben’s Kosher Deli’s menu, is, well, heaven. To smother one in a dripping, hefty side order of baked beans accompanied by fresh-cut French fries and another side or two, well—can you say “euphoric, majestic mess of a feast?” Long Island voters sure can! National Winner. Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Multiple Locations. nathansfamous.com You can count on these hot dogs to deliver the goods. From Nathan’s humble start in 1916 as a nickel hot-dog stand at Coney Island, the franchise has grown far and wide. But it’s never forgotten what made it famous in the first place. These frankfurters are full of flavor in every bite and go perfectly with a massive boat of their signature Cheese Fries!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Best Hot Dogs on Long Island!
1. Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Multiple Locations. nathansfamous.com 2. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessan Multiple Locations. bensdeli.net 3. Flo’s Luncheonette 302 Middle Rd., Blue Point. 888-FLOS-TOGO. flosfamous.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Best Hot Dogs on Long Island!
1. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Multiple Locations. www.bensdeli.net 2. Flo’s Luncheonette 302 Middle Rd., Blue Point. 888-FLOS-TOGO. www.flosfamous.com 3. Smokin’ Al’s Multiple Locations. www.smokinals.com NATIONAL Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Multiple Locations. www.nathansfamous.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Best Hot Dogs on Long Island!
1. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Multiple Locations. www.bensdeli.net 2. Bad Dawgs 44 Gerard St., Huntington. 631-923-1201. www.baddawgs.com 3. Smokin Al’s Multiple Locations. www.smokinals.com NATIONAL Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Multiple Locations. www.nathansfamous.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Best Hot Dogs on Long Island!
1. Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Locations. www.nathansfamous.com 2. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Multiple Locations. www.bensdeli.net 3. Bad Dawgs 44 Gerard St., Huntington. 631-923-1201. www.baddawgsli.com NATIONAL Five Guys Burger and Fries Multiple Locations. www.fiveguys.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Best Hot Dogs on Long Island!
1. Nathan’s Famous Restaurant Multiple locations www.nathansfamous.com 2. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Multiple locations. www.bensdeli.net 3. Five Guys Burgers and Fries Multiple locations. www.fiveguys.com