Best LGBTQ Bar on Long Island

2023: Long Islanders Voted Cherries on the Bay Best LGBTQ Bar!

Cherries on the Bay
158 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove
(631) 597-7859 – cherrysonthebay.com

If you’re looking for an LGBTQ-friendly drinking spot overlooking The Great Peconic Bay, stop at Cherry’s on the Bay. In the heart of Cherry Grove, historically known as the first gay and lesbian town, lies a Fire Island classic. From an array of sunset views, killer cocktails, and captivating drag shows, Cherry’s on the Bay really has it all. Come visit this one-stop shop for all things dancing, food and drink, and stellar sunset views. Check out their nightly shows showcasing Fire Island’s most entertaining drag queens Monday-Sunday so you won’t miss a beer. Eat, drink, and be Cherry!