Best Beer Selection on Long Island

Long Islanders love to have choices, and that certainly applies to beer. Almost any selection of beer is good, but if there’s more to choose from, that makes the night better than it already promised to be. Restaurants, bars and pubs serving a wide variety of this “hoppening” brew are always higher up on the list of great places to go. This year, head over to the home of the Best Beer Selection on Long Island and see for yourself.

2024: Long Island Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Beer Selection!

Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 – poboybrewery.com

Po’Boy Brewery boasts an exceptional beer selection that caters to diverse palates and preferences. Renowned for its commitment to craft brewing, this brewery offers a curated menu of high-quality beers, ranging from hop-forward IPAs and rich stouts to refreshing ales and innovative seasonal brews. The expert brewers at Po’Boy Brewery bring creativity and precision to each batch, ensuring a delightful and varied experience for patrons. With a dedication to both classic styles and experimental flavors, the beer selection reflects the brewery’s passion for pushing the boundaries of craft beer. Whether enjoying a flight of samples or sipping on a favorite pint, Po’Boy Brewery invites beer enthusiasts to explore a world of flavors.

2023: Long Islanders Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Beer Selection!

Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St., Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 – poboybrewery.com

We’ve all been there — you walk into a bar and find yourself extremely disappointed in the beer selection. At Po’Boy Brewery in Port Jefferson Station, this simply will not be the case. The brewery has a great selection of craft beer and ciders to choose from. From pilsners and IPAs to stouts and porters, there’s a beer for every palate. Plus, they don’t just have traditional hard ciders at Po’Boy — you’ll find that many of their offerings have different fruits like mango and pomegranate that you just have to try. If you want to try a few of the different beers and ciders, you can order a flight and find which one is your favorite!

2022: Long Islanders Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Beer Selection!

Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 – poboybrewery.com

2021: Long Islanders Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Beer Selection!

Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 – poboybrewery.com

Po’Boy Brewery, located in Port Jefferson Station, boasts a beautiful and cozy taproom and welcoming staff. Most have called us a pleasant and fun place to unwind and get together with friends and family. We are one of the few places in the country that is identified as a Brewery and a Cidery! We rotate our taps regularly so that you can experience a new flavor and style weekly! The Tasting Room and Sour Patch have over 20 varieties of beer and cider to sample flights and to order pints from. Growlers can be filled and four-packs can be purchased for off-premise consumption as well. Several food options to choose from, special events and celebrations, live music on specified nights, and we also offer options of all varieties for hosting your special event. It has been a pure joy to grow, expand and define our unique, innovative approach to craft beer and we have had a damn good time doing it! Thank you for your support and for voting us the BEST on Long Island! We will see you on the other side of the bar!

2020: Long Islanders Voted Great South Bay Brewery Best Beer Selection On Long Island!

Great South Bay Brewery
25 Drexel Dr, Bay Shore
(631) 392-8472 – greatsouthbaybrewery.com

There is no shortage of beer selection at the Great South Bay Brewery. From popular brews such as their Blood Orange Pale Ale to Blonde Ambition Blonde Ale to a plethora of seasonal and limited release selections, there is always something for everyone. All of their beers are craft brewed using the highest quality malts and the finest hops they can get their hands on. Flight options consisting of a combination of their 15 beers on tap are also available so you can enjoy a bit of everything before committing to the drink of your choice!

Directions: 25 Drexel Drive Bay Shore, NY 11706. On the right side of the street when coming from 5th Ave. We are across the street from UTZ and Chase Bank on Drexel Drive. Look for the big Great South Bay Sign on our building!

Visit Our Website Follow Us on Instagram Like Us on Facebook Untapped WeddingWire TripAdvisor

2019: Long Islanders Voted Croxley’s Ale House & Eatery Best Beer Selection On Long Island!

Croxley’s Ale House & Eatery
Multiple Locations
www.croxley.com

They really know how to pour it on at Croxley’s Ale House, a Long Island original that’s grown in popularity and appreciation. Its venue in Smithtown features 80 taps! But don’t forsake its other locations: 68 taps at Farmingdale, 60 taps at Franklin Square and 50 taps at Rockville Centre. Add them all up and they’re tops in taps! They’ve got a whole lot of quality brews sure to satisfy everyone. No thirst remains unquenchable at Croxley’s, thanks to its wide assortment of craft beer, imports and specialties. These mugs come with a hug, too!

2018: Due to a balloting issue, there was no winner for the beer selection category. This category will return next year.

2017: Long Islanders Voted Croxley’s Ale House & Eatery Best Beer Selection on Long Island!

Croxley’s Ale House & Eatery Multiple Locations. croxley.com

2016: Long Islanders Voted Croxley’s Ale House & Eatery Best Beer Selection on Long Island!

Croxley’s Ale House & Eatery Multiple Locations. croxley.com