A good cocktail doesn’t taste great just because of the alcohol it’s mixed with. It all starts with the bartender. He or she is responsible for concocting the best combination of liquor and mixer. From our signature Long Island Ice Tea to a simple rum and coke, every drink should be made with care. If you want a good drink this year, then go to the location of the Best Bartenders on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Bartenders!
Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 – poboybrewery.com
The bartenders at Po’Boy Brewery are the heartbeat of this establishment, infusing each visit with warmth, knowledge, and a passion for exceptional brews. Known for their friendly demeanor and extensive knowledge of the brewery’s offerings, Po’Boy Brewery’s bartenders elevate the customer experience. With a keen understanding of the diverse beer selection, these professionals guide patrons through a journey of flavors, recommending brews that suit individual tastes. Their engaging personalities create a convivial atmosphere, turning casual visits into memorable experiences. Whether sharing insights about the brewing process or offering personalized recommendations, the bartenders at Po’Boy Brewery contribute to the welcoming and community-driven spirit that makes this establishment a cherished destination for craft beer lovers on Long Island.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Bartenders!
Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St., Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 – poboybrewery.com
A good bartender can elevate any bar experience. The bartenders at Po’Boy Brewery in Port Jefferson Station are truly the best in the biz. The family owned and operated brewery is very careful about who they put behind the bar because they want to ensure that everyone who walks through the door is treated like family. Each bartender at Po’Boy Brewery is knowledgeable on every brew that is served, so even a craft beer novice can rest easy knowing that with the bartender’s help, you can find a delicious drink to enjoy with your friends and family. Be sure to come by and ask a “Po’Boytender” what the day’s specials are.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Bartenders!
Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St., Building E3, Port Jefferson Station
631-828-1131 – poboybrewery.com
A good bartender can elevate any bar experience. The bartenders at Po’Boy Brewery in Port Jefferson Station are truly the best in the biz. The family owned and operated brewery is very careful about who they put behind the bar because they want to ensure that everyone who walks through the door is treated like family. Each bartender at Po’Boy Brewery is knowledgeable on every brew that is served, so even a craft beer novice can rest easy knowing that with the bartender’s help, you can find a delicious drink to enjoy with your friends and family. Be sure to come by and ask a “Po’Boytender” what the day’s specials are!
2021: Long Islanders Voted One Eye Jacks Best Bartenders!
One Eye Jacks
380 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 342-1732 – facebook.com/oneeyejacksli
There’s nothing quite like a great bartender who knows how to make your favorite drink, and that is exactly what you’ll find at One Eye Jacks. For the third year in a row, One Eye Jacks has been named the Bethpage Best of Long Island winner for Best Bartender, and when you stop by for a visit you will see why. The eatery’s bartenders can handle any drink you order, no matter how complex, and will have it to your seat in a timely fashion. Whether you want one of the bar’s famous beer towers or fish bowls or having a low key night with a draft beer, the bartenders at One Eye Jacks will serve you with a smile.
2020: Long Islanders Voted One Eye Jacks Best Bartenders On Long Island!
One Eye Jacks
380 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 342-1732 – facebook.com/oneeyejacksli
Great service with a smile is what sets apart the bartenders at One Eye Jacks from all the rest. One Eye Jacks is a family-owned venue and each customer is treated like a part of the family from the bartending staff. The bartenders make the perfect cocktails every time. The “Fun Joey” is even named after their head bartender and now Manager. If you truly want a place where you are treated special, have a perfect cocktail in an intimate environment, One Eye Jacks is the place to go.
2019: Long Islanders Voted One Eye Jacks Best Bartenders On Long Island!
One Eye Jacks
380 N Wantagh Ave., Bethpage
(516) 342-1732 – www.facebook.com/oneeyejacksli
Great service from great people is what sets the bartenders at One Eye Jacks apart from all other bartenders on Long Island. There’s nothing like finding a local neighborhood pub that treats you like a friend and valued customer every time you walk in. That’s exactly the kind of treatment you can expect at One Eye Jacks to go along with great drinks and food. To borrow from a classic sitcom, the bartenders make One Eye Jacks customers feel like they’ve gone to a place “where everybody knows your name.”
2018: Long Islanders Voted Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge Best Bartenders on Long Island
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
4 Patchogue Dr., Rocky Point
631-744-4100
spiroslounge.com
A great bartender not only knows how to prepare exceptional drinks, but how to set the customer’s mind at ease, too. A great bartender is an open ear who will listen to you, a trusted confidante, and a caring friend. Spiro’s, which consistently ranks atop a number of categories in this competitive contest, is not only home to phenomenal food and drinks, but extraordinary bartenders, too! They’re masters of mixology, as well as extraordinary people, who genuinely care about each and every customer. No wonder why Long Islanders declare Spiro’s fantastic team the Best Bartenders on Long Island!
2017: Long Islanders Voted Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge Best Bartenders on Long Island
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
4 Patchogue Dr., Rocky Point. 631-744-4100. spiroslounge.com
A great bartender not only knows how to prepare exceptional drinks, but how to set the customer’s mind at ease, too. A great bartender is an open ear who will listen to you, a trusted confidante, and a caring friend. Spiro’s, which consistently ranks atop a number of categories in this competitive contest, is not only home to phenomenal food and drinks, but extraordinary bartenders, too! They’re masters of mixology, as well as extraordinary people, who genuinely care about each and every customer. No wonder why Long Islanders declare Spiro’s fantastic team the Best Bartenders on Long Island!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge Best Bartenders on Long Island
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
4 Patchogue Dr., Rocky Point. 631-744-4100. spiroslounge.com
Here’s a toast to Spiro Karachopan, born in Greece in 1954, who has made his mark on Long Island nightlife in 2016 by having the best bartenders on Long Island for Spiro’s Lounge & Restaurant, which rightfully bears his name. Are you thirsty, friends? Here’s looking at you. The cocktails are shaken, stirred, on the rocks or served straight up, whatever your pleasure. These mixologists are the masters of their craft. The cocktails are amazing. The scene is hopping, and the atmosphere is full of fun and good cheer. From the drinks to the food, Spiro’s is the place to be.
2015: Long Islanders Voted BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant Best Bartenders on Long Island!
BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant
67 W. Main St., Patchogue. 631-447-2337. brickhousebrewery.com
You would figure that a great bar as picked by the voters in the Best Bar category would also host the Best Bartenders, because its hard to have one without the other. Quenching their patrons thirst is a given. They set the bar at a higher level. All you have to do is raise your glass. The bartenders at the BrickHouse are the masters of the mix. Day or night, they know how to go with the flow and pour it just right every time. And as all great bartenders, they’re also excellent listeners.
2014: Long Islanders Voted BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant in Patchogue Best Bartenders on Long Island!
1. BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant
67 W. Main St., Patchogue. 631-447-2337. brickhousebrewery.com
You would figure that a great bar as picked by the voters in the Best Bar category would also host the Best Bartenders, because it’s to hard to have one without the other. Quenching their patrons’ thirst is a given. They set the bar at a higher level. All you have to do is raise your glass. The bartenders at the BrickHouse are the masters of the mix. Day or night, they know how to go with the flow and pour it just right every time. And as all great bartenders, they’re also excellent listeners.
2. The Nutty Irishman
Multiple Locations. thenuttyirishman.com
3. Croxley’s Ale House & Eatery
Multiple Locations. croxley.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Post Office Café in Babylon Best Bartenders on Long Island!
1. Post Office Café
130 W. Main St., Babylon. 631-669-9224. www.lessings.com
2. Even Flow Bar and Grill
150 E. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-665-9696. www.evenflowbarandgrill.com
3. Brick House Brewery
67 W. Main St., Patchogue. 631-447-2337. www.brickhousebrewery.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Shandon Court in East Islip Best Bartenders on Long Island!
1. Shandon Court
115 E. Main St., East Islip. 631-581-5678. www.shandoncourt.com
2. EvenFlow Bar and Grill
150 E. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-665-9696
3. Croxley Ale House
Multiple Locations. www.croxley.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Croxley’s Ale House Best Bartenders on Long Island!
1. Croxley’s Ale House
Multiple locations. www.croxley.com
2. Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall
Multiple locations. www.muls.com
3. Post Office Café
130 W. Main Street, Babylon. 631-669-9224. www.lessings.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted Mulcahy’s Pub and Concert Hall In Wantagh And Centereach The Best Bartenders On Long Island!
1. Mulcahy’s Pub and Concert Hall
3232 Railroad Ave., Wantagh 516-783-7500.
2. Croxley Ales.
Multiple locations. www.croxley.com
3. The Crazy Donkey Bar & Grill
1058 Broad Hollow Rd., Farmingdale. 631-753-1975. www.thecrazydonkey.com
