Thrift stores are the places for savvy shoppers to discover real finds, and not just Macklemore! What’s old is new again to a thrifty shopper. Here are some of the best thrift stores on Long Island. Now get to popping tags!
2024: Long Island Voted Remember Yesteryears Best Thrift / Consignment Store!
Remember Yesteryears
901 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale
(631) 654-3052 – rememberyesteryears.com
In the heart of Oakdale, Long Island, Remember Yesteryears stands as the top Long Island destination for antique enthusiasts, offering an expansive 15,000 square feet of curated treasures from over 100 dealers! A haven for nostalgia, the store boasts a diverse collection of antiques, collectibles, and a dedicated jewelry center, inviting visitors to embark on a journey through the rich tapestry of yesteryears. Customer testimonials sing praises for Remember Yesteryears, describing it as the go-to antique store with a vast array of items catering to diverse interests. The accommodating staff, well-organized layout, and the convenience of item retrieval at the checkout counter enhance the shopping experience. Visitors appreciate the cleanliness, clear signage, and the availability of a restroom!
2023: Long Islanders Voted Remember Yesteryears Best Thrift / Consignment Store!
Remember Yesteryears
901 Montauk Hwy., Oakdale
(631) 654-3052 – rememberyesteryears.com
Who doesn’t love a good thrift shopping outing? For used goods that come at low prices, thrifting is the way to go. Depending on what you’re looking for, though, your thrifting trip could be hit or miss. More times than not, a visit to Remember Yesteryears in Oakdale will be a hit because of its wide selection of items, from furniture and jewelry to clothing and military paraphernalia. There is no knowing what you will discover amongst these walls, but one thing is for sure, it is easy to get lost so try to go there with a plan in mind. This store gives you the unique opportunity to shop collections from 120 dealers all under one roof. So take your thrift shopping to the next level and head over to Remember Yesteryears!
2022: Long Islanders Voted Remember Yesteryears Antique Mall Best Thrift/Consignment Store!
Remember Yesteryears Antique Mall
901 Montauk Hwy., Oakdale
(631) 654-3052 – rememberyesteryears.com
Who doesn’t love a good thrift shopping outing? For used goods that come at low prices, thrifting is the way to go. Depending on what you’re looking for, though, your thrifting trip could be hit or miss. More times than not, a visit to Remember Yesteryears in Oakdale will be a hit because of its wide selection of items, from furniture and jewelry to clothing and military paraphernalia. There is no knowing what you will discover amongst these walls, but one thing is for sure, it is easy to get lost so try to go there with a plan in mind. This store gives you the unique opportunity to shop collections from 120 dealers all under one roof. So take your thrift shopping to the next level and head over to Remember Yesteryears!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Options for Community Living Thrift Shop Best Thrift/Consignment Store!
Options for Community Living Thrift Shop
392 Hawkins Ave, Ronkonkoma
(631) 676-4579 – optionscl.org
Though thrifting has become popular in recent years, there are many families who rely on thrift and consignment stores to clothe themselves and their families. Options for Community Living Thrift Shop is completely committed to helping Long Island’s neediest residents so they live more productive and stable lives. The thrift shop fosters a welcoming environment so those in need can come and find the items they need. The shop accepts donations of a variety of items in new or good condition all year round, so the next time you are doing some spring cleaning, check out the thrift shop’s website to see what you can donate and help your fellow Long Islanders.
2020: Long Islanders Voted Antique Attics Best Thrift/Consignment Store!
Antique Attics
2789 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove
(631) 588-0005 – antiqueattics.com
Antique Attics has the largest, most affordable and personalized selection of gifts and stocking stuffers for the entire family! Open seven days a week, they offer new inventory daily, as well as reasonable buy-and-trade options. Customers fuel their passion and make the days enjoyable. On top of that, the treasures that people bring in to sell everyday adds to the excitement. Hearing the unique stories of each item and the history behind them is why they’re in this business. They don’t just sell merchandise here, they sell history, love, and lasting memories!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Antique Attics Best Thrift/Consignment Store!
Antique Attics
2789 Middle Country Rd., Lake Grove
(631) 588-0005 – www.antiqueattics.com
Antique Attics has the largest, most affordable and personalized selection of gifts and stocking stuffers for the entire family! Open seven days a week, they offer new inventory daily, as well as reasonable buy-and-trade options. Customers fuel their passion and make the days enjoyable. On top of that, the treasures that people bring in to sell everyday adds to the excitement. Hearing the unique stories of each item and the history behind them is why they’re in this business. They don’t just sell merchandise here, they sell history, love, and lasting memories!
2018: Long Islanders Voted Island Thrift Store Best Thrift/Consignment Store on Long Island!
Island Thrift Store
Multiple Locations
islandthriftstore.com
At any of Island Thrift Store’s locations, you’ll never run out of intriguing new finds. That’s because they stock their shelves with new items daily. That means that every day there are new undiscovered treasures among their clothing, jewelry, books, furniture, and household items. Plus, daily price specials mean that you’ll get a great bargain. And if your closet’s full to bursting, bring in your as-new items for your neighbors to browse. Whether you’re a collector looking to add to your shelf of rare vinyl or a fashionista who just can’t turn down a vintage look, there’s something for you at Island Thrift Store.
2017: Long Islanders Voted Lucky Finds Boutique Best Thrift / Consignment Store on Long Island!
Lucky Finds Boutique
7A N. Park Ave., Rockville Centre. 516-442-4600. facebook.com/Luckyfindsboutique
If you’re looking to get designer & brand name items without breaking the bank stop at Lucky Finds Boutique. This is the fourth year in a row that Long Island had voted Lucky Finds Boutiques the best consignment store. This trendy consignment boutique carries designer clothing, shoes, handbags & accessories at fantastic prices! With a friendly and helpful staff, who can help you find an outfit for any occasion, it’s no wonder why Lucky finds Boutique is constantly voted the best!
National Winner: Savers
Multiple Locations. savers.com
Known as a “Thrift Superstore,” Savers offers a huge selection of great quality, gently used clothing, accessories and household goods, among so much more, all at amazing prices. Looking for something unique, or just the basics? Whatever you need, you’re guaranteed to find it, and at a great price. Looking to donate some of your gently used items? Savers will gladly accept them, consequently saving them from the landfill, and make them available for reuse to all of its beloved customers. For more than 60 years, Savers has been assisting communities with this “Pass It Along” philosophy, and countless families are so much better off because of it! Savers is thrift heaven!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Lucky Finds Boutique Best Thrift / Consignment Store on Long Island!
Lucky Finds Boutique
7A N. Park Ave., Rockville Centre. 516-442-4600. facebook.com/Luckyfindsboutique 44444
This is the third year in a row Lucky Finds Boutiques has topped this category, and for many good reasons. First, there’s its wide selection: hundreds of brand name clothing and accessories, including designer handbags, jewelry, shoes and boots. Then, there’s the staff: knowledgeable and friendly and always looking to help customers find that sought-after little piece of wardrobe heaven!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Lucky Finds Boutique Best Thrift / Consignment Store on Long Island!
Lucky Finds Boutique
7A N. Park Ave., Rockville Centre. 516-442-4600.
Lucky Finds certainly lives up to its name. Opened in 2011, the boutique carries women’s clothing, shoes, handbags and accessories from some of the top names in fashion, at great prices. From David Yurman and Tory Burch to UGG and Lululemon, the selection here is sure to satisfy any shopaholic or fashionista. If you’re in the mood to peruse, you just may find yourself lucky in this unique treasure trove!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Lucky Finds Boutique in Farmingdale Best Thrift / Consignment Store on Long Island!
1. Lucky Finds Boutique
7A N. Park Ave., Rockville Centre. 516-442-4600. facebook.com/Luckyfindsboutique
2. Yard Sale Depot
1560 Ocean Ave., Bohemia. 631-561-1023. shopyardsaledepot.com
3. The Barkin’ Basement
116 E. Main St., Port Jefferson. 631-642-2275.
2013: Long Islanders Voted Salvage Chic Boutique in Long Beach Best Thrift / Consignment Store on Long Island!
1. Salvage Chic Boutique
156 E. Park Ave., Long Beach. 516-992-0444. www.salvagechicboutique.com
2. Cassidy’s Closet
4853 Merrick Rd., Massapequa Park. 516-557-2995
3. Kiss Consignment
6166 Jericho Tpke., Commack. 631-979-5477. www.kissconsignment.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Community Thrift Shop in Huntington Best Thrift Store on Long Island!
1. Community Thrift Shop
274 New York Ave., Huntington. 631-271-4883. www.fsl-li.org/programs/familyservices_The_Community_Thrift_Shop.php
2. Kiss It Goodbuy
6166 Jericho Tpke., Commack, NY 11725. 631-979-5477. www.kissconsignment.com
3. The Barkin Basement
116 E. Main St., Port Jefferson. 631-642-2275
2011: Long Islanders Voted Selden Thrift in Selden the Best Thrift / Consignment Store on Long Island!
1. Selden Thrift
614 Middle Country Rd., Selden. 631-736-3979.
2. Junior League of Long Island
1395 Old Northern Blvd., Roslyn. 516-621-4890. www.jlli.org
3. Community Thrift Shop
274 New York Ave., Huntington. 631-271-4883.
National
Salvation Army
Multiple locations. www.salvationarmyusa.org
2010: Long Islanders Voted Community Thrift Shop in Huntington Best Thrift / Consignment Store on Long Island!
1. Community Thrift Shop Inc.
274 New York Ave., Huntington. 631-271-4883
2. American Cancer Society Thrift Shop
22 Nugent St., Southampton. 631-283-6789.
3. Act II Consignment Boutique
11 Hewitt Sq., East Northport. 631-754-1800.
National
Salvation Army
Multiple locations. www.salvationarmyusa.org
