We want our pets to be satisfied and more. Fortunately, there are stores where you can fulfill all of your pets’ needs. From food and supplements, to toys and collars, to cages and tanks, you can find whatever your looking for all in one place. And for the best brands, prices and customer service, look no further than the Best Pet Shop on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted The Left Paw Best Pet Shop!
The Left Paw
411 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park
(516) 305-4220 – theleftpaw.com
The Left Paw is home to your pets and their needs! A pet shop where you can find a wide selection of healthy and happy puppies, along with the supplies needed to care for your new four-legged friend. The Left Paw’s puppies are sourced from reputable, licensed breeders with guaranteed pedigree and quality. All pups are visited at least once a week by Dr. Mehlrose, a licensed veterinarian, to ensure each puppy is free from any illnesses. Each puppy is vaccinated the moment they arrive at The Left Paw, and a puppy is never sold if they have a cold or a medical issue. Their dedicated team shares your passion for dogs and is committed to offering their expertise and support to help you choose the most perfect pup for your family!
2023: Long Islanders Voted The Left Paw Best Pet Shop On Long Island!
The Left Paw
411 Jericho Tpke, New Hyde Park
(516) 305-4220 – theleftpaw.com
It’s time to stock up on pet supplies! The best place to go on Long Island for all of your pet’s needs is The Left Paw. Located in New Hyde Park, The Left Paw is completely stocked with anything you could ever want from a pet store. From food and toys to beds and cleaning items, the Left Paw is your one-stop shop for dog supplies. Plus, there’s one thing here that you can’t find at a lot of pet shops — puppies! That’s right, if you are in the market for a puppy, you can head right over to The Left Paw and see who they have available. Regardless of if you are looking to buy a new puppy or have a few already at home, The Left Paw is the place to shop!
2022: Long Islanders Voted The Left Paw Best Pet Shop On Long Island!
The Left Paw
411 Jericho Tpke, New Hyde Park
(516) 305-4220 – theleftpaw.com
It’s time to stock up on pet supplies! The best place to go on Long Island for all of your pet’s needs is The Left Paw. Located in New Hyde Park, The Left Paw is completely stocked with anything you could ever want from a pet store. From food and toys to beds and cleaning items, the Left Paw is your one-stop shop for dog supplies. Plus, there’s one thing here that you can’t find at a lot of pet shops — puppies! That’s right, if you are in the market for a puppy, you can head right over to The Left Paw and see who they have available. Regardless of if you are looking to buy a new puppy or have a few already at home, The Left Paw is the place to shop!
2021: Long Islanders Voted The Left Paw Best Pet Shop On Long Island!
The Left Paw
411 Jericho Tpke, New Hyde Park
(516) 305-4220 – theleftpaw.com
Are you ready to bring a canine companion into your life? Do you want to see your fuzzy pal wagging their tail all the time? The Left Paw is the place for you! With every kind of dog toy, bed, treat or grooming material you may be looking for, The Left Paw is your one-stop-shop for everything your puppy needs. Take a trip with your pooch to get some new treats or toys, or go and check out its selection of puppies in need of forever homes. The staff and team are passionate about dogs and more than anything wants you and your furry friend to have a happy life. The Left Paw is always available if you are ever in need of advice or assistance with your pup!
2020: Long Islanders Voted The Left Paw Best Pet Shop On Long Island!
The Left Paw
411 Jericho Tpke, New Hyde Park
(516) 305-4220 – theleftpaw.com
Do you own a dog? Do you want to? The Left Paw is the place for you! With every kind of dog toy, bed, treat or grooming material you may need, The Left Paw is your one-stop-shop for everything your puppy could ever need or want. Take a trip with your pup to get some new treats or toys, or go and check out their selection of puppies in need of forever homes! The staff and team are passionate about dogs and more than anything wants you and your pup to have a happy life.The Left Paw is always available if you are ever in need of advice or assistance with your pup!
2019: Long Islanders Voted The Left Paw Best Pet Shop!
The Left Paw
411 Jericho Tpke., New Hyde Park
(516) 305-4220 – www.theleftpaw.com
The Left Paw is your new right-hand man for anything and everything pet-related. This New Hyde Park pet shop offers an array of pet merchandise, as well as adorable pooches waiting eagerly to find their forever homes. Interested in getting a new brush for your precious pup? Not a pawblem! Want to buy new toys for your dog to play with? They’ve got it! From bowls and carriers to beds and leashes, The Left Paw has it all, always at affordable prices!
2018: Long Islanders Voted The Left Paw Best Pet Shop on Long Island
The Left Paw
411 Jericho Tpke., New Hyde Park. 516-305-4220. theleftpaw.com
The Left Paw is your new right-hand man for anything and everything pet-related. This New Hyde Park pet shop offers an array of pet merchandise, as well as adorable pooches waiting eagerly to find their forever homes. Interested in getting a new brush for your precious pup? Not a pawblem! Want to buy new toys for your dog to play with? They’ve got it! From bowls and carriers to beds and leashes, The Left Paw has it all, and at affordable prices!
2017: Long Islanders Voted The Left Paw Best Pet Shop on Long Island
The Left Paw
411 Jericho Tpke., New Hyde Park. 516-305-4220. theleftpaw.com
The Left Paw is your new right-hand man for anything and everything pet-related. This New Hyde Park pet shop offers an array of pet merchandise, as well as adorable pooches waiting eagerly to find their forever homes. Interested in getting a new brush for your precious pup? Not a pawblem! Want to buy new toys for your dog to play with? They’ve got it! From bowls and carriers to beds and leashes, The Left Paw has it all, and at affordable prices!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Animal Appetites Best Pet Shop on Long Island
Animal Appetites, Ltd.
1918 Wantagh Ave., Wantagh. 516-785-5142. facebook.com/animalappetites
Animal Appetites, Ltd. in Wantagh has been selling high-quality pet items since 1979. With its massive selection of products, fair prices, and friendly staff, pet owners will never want to shop anywhere else. Looking for some chew toys for your dog? Not a problem. In need of feline furniture? No sweat. Pondering the purchase of a pet bed? That’s easy. You’ll be able to find everything you need right in one place.
2016: Long Islanders Voted Animal Appetites Best Pet Shop on Long Island
Animal Appetites, Ltd.
1918 Wantagh Ave., Wantagh. 516-785-5142. facebook.com/animalappetites
Animal Appetites, Ltd. in Wantagh has been selling high-quality pet items since 1979. With its massive selection of products, fair prices, and friendly staff, pet owners will never want to shop anywhere else. Looking for some chew toys for your dog? Not a problem. In need of feline furniture? No sweat. Pondering the purchase of a pet bed? That’s easy. You’ll be able to find everything you need right in one place.
2015: Long Islanders Voted Community Pet Shop Best Pet Shop on Long Island!
Community Pet Shop
347 New York Ave., Huntington. 631-421-0088.
From dog strollers to Duck Dynasty toys to the most comfortable bedding, collars and too many accessories to list here. Community Pet Store has proved to all of Long Island that they indeed are your one-stop spot for everything pet and pet-related. Staffed by a knowledgeable team of animal lovers, they will help you find the best for your pet.
2014: Long Islanders Voted Community Pet Shop in Huntington Best Pet Shop on Long Island!
1. Community Pet Shop
347 New York Ave., Huntington. 631-421-0088. facebook.com/Community-Pet-Shop
2. Animal Appetites, Ltd.
1918 Wantagh Ave., Wantagh. 516-785-5142.
3. Pet Supplies Plus
Multiple Locations. 866-477-7748. petsuppliesplus.com
National
PetSmart
Multiple Locations. petsmart.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Just Dogs! Gourmet Bakery in East Northport Best Pet Shop on Long Island!
1. Just Dogs! Gourmet Barkery
3 Hewitt Square, East Northport. 631-651-9292. www.justdogsgourmetny.com
2. Love My Puppies
745 Wantagh Ave., Wantagh. 516-804-5399. www.lovemypuppiesny.com
3. Pet Supplies Plus
Multiple Locations. www.petsuppliesplus.com
National
Petco
Multiple Locations. www.petco.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Love My Puppies Best Pet Shop on Long Island!
1. Love My Puppies
745 Wantagh Ave., Wantagh. 516-804-5399. lovemypuppiesny.com
2. Mutts & Butts
2076 Merrick Rd., Merrick. 516-379-6391 www.muttsandbutts.com
3. Pet Supplies Plus
Multiple Locations. www.petsuppliesplus.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Selmer’s Pet Land in South Huntington the Best Pet Shop on Long Island!
1. Selmer’s Pet Land
125 E. Jericho Tpke., South Huntington. 631-423-4677. www.selmerspetland.com
2. Love My Puppies
745 Wantagh Ave., Wantagh. 516-804-5399. www.lovemypuppiesny.com
3. The Peticular Pet
71 E. Main St., Huntington. 631-427-7328. www.peticularpet.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted Selmer’s Pet Land in South Huntington the Best Pet Shop on Long Island!
1. Selmer’s Pet Land
125 E. Jericho Tpke., South Huntington. 631-423-4677. www.selmerspetland.com
2. Love My Puppies
745 Wantagh Ave., Wantagh. 516-804-5399. www.lovemypuppiesny.com
3. Parrots of the World
316 Sunrise Hwy., Rockville Centre. 516-764-0717. www.parrotsoftheworld.com