Long Island’s lighthouses, sentinels of the sea, stand tall with stories as enduring as their brick and mortar, each one offers a mesmerizing glimpse into history and maritime romance. Get ready to cast your anchor and chart a course towards the Best Lighthouse on Long Island as voted by Best of Long Island readers!
2026: Long Islanders Voted Montauk Point Lighthouse Best Lighthouse!
Montauk Point Lighthouse
2000 Montauk Highway, Montauk
(631) 668-2544 – montaukhistoricalsociety.org
Montauk Point Lighthouse is one of Long Island’s most iconic historic landmarks and the first lighthouse built in New York State. Authorized by the Second U.S. Congress under President George Washington in 1792 and completed in 1796, it remains an active beacon and is the fourth-oldest working lighthouse in the United States. The lighthouse stands at the easternmost tip of Long Island and offers sweeping 360° views of the Atlantic Ocean and Block Island Sound. Visitors can explore the museum and climb the tower during operating hours to learn about its maritime heritage and significance in American history. Operated by the Montauk Historical Society, Montauk Point Lighthouse was designated a National Historic Landmark in 2012, recognizing its cultural and navigational importance.
2025: Long Islanders Voted Fire Island Lighthouse Best Lighthouse!
Fire Island Lighthouse
Field 5, Robert Moses State Park,
(631) 583-5901 – fireislandlighthouse.com
The views from the top of the Fire Island Lighthouse overlooking the Great South Bay are pretty spectacular, and you can even see the New York City skyline on an unclouded day. Visitors also enjoy a museum gift shop open from 10 a.m. to4 p.m. Once they climb to the top, a friendly, knowledgeable guide can fill them in on historical information that enhances the view. Each year, the Lighthouse sponsors fundraising events like an Online Silent Auction and a Keeper’s Craft Tasting to help preserve the lighthouse, which continues to aid in navigation. Swimming, sunbathing, hiking, and biking are popular activities for visitors who want to make a day of it during Long Island’s splendid summer months.
2024: Long Island Voted Fire Island Lighthouse Best Lighthouse!
Fire Island Lighthouse
Field 5, Robert Moses State Park,
(631) 583-5901 – fireislandlighthouse.com
The Fire Island Lighthouse is a coastal marvel, gracing the shores of Long Island with its historic allure. Standing proudly since 1858, this iconic structure has served as a guiding light for sailors navigating the Atlantic. Perched at the western tip of Fire Island, the lighthouse offers spectacular vistas of the surrounding marine landscape. Visitors can climb its 182 steps to the top, where breathtaking panoramic views await. Situated within the picturesque Robert Moses State Park, the lighthouse becomes a focal point for both maritime history enthusiasts and nature seekers. Surrounded by pristine beaches and dunes, the Fire Island Lighthouse at Robert Moses State Park is a cherished landmark that harmoniously blends history, natural beauty, and coastal charm.