Long Island is a popular destination for travelers during any season. Whether they’re here to visit family, New York City or the numerous beautiful beaches, we can guarantee they’ll need a place to stay, and there are hotels all around for just that, and there are hotel all around for just that. Hotels are also convenient if you’re renovating your home and can’t stay in it for a few days. If you or someone else needs a hotel, then look no further than the Best Hotel on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted Garden City Hotel Best Hotel!
Garden City Hotel
45 Seventh St, Garden City
(516) 747-3000 – gardencityhotel.com
With more than 150 years of style and service behind it, The Garden City Hotel is a Long Island landmark of style and service that is a beloved and timeless treat. Featuring spacious guest rooms, luxurious suites and a top-notch culinary team, the historic hotel is known for its genuine hospitality.Centrally located in the heart of Garden City, generations of travelers and locals alike have discovered the incredible history and classic elegance of the hotel that boasts 269 guest rooms and suites; numerous bars and lounges; a legendary Sunday brunch; 30,000 feet of meeting and event space, wedding packages, a fitness center and much more! In addition, numerous local attractions include the UBS arena, Westbury Music Fair, museums, beaches and top-notch golf courses including the noted Bethpage Black.
2023: Long Islanders Voted East Wind Long Island Best Hotel!
East Wind Long Island
5720 Route 25A, Wading River
(631) 929-3500 – eastwindlongisland.com
A wedding reception at East Wind Long Island will be unforgettable to any pair of sweethearts who choose this hotel for their celebration. The most amazing cocktail hour you’ll ever experience is what people say about this elegant venue. It’s the kind of hotel you’ll want for family meetups for the holidays. Give the Thanksgiving buffet a whirl when the holiday rolls around or tell your loved ones to make reservations so you can all enjoy a holiday weekend together or a family reunion here together. The stunning East Wind, which employs culinary talent in the restaurant and genteel professionals to take care of guests, is the kind of place to book any time locals want a stay-cation or out-of-towners come to visit!
2022: Long Islanders Voted The Inn at Fox Hollow Best Hotel!
The Inn at Fox Hollow
7755 Jericho Tpke, Woodbury
(516) 224-8100 – theinnatfoxhollow.com
All the luxury of Long Island’s Gold Coast can be enjoyed at The Inn at Fox Hollow in Woodbury. This boutique hotel offers guests high-end amenities and a serene, comfortable atmosphere. Guests from near and far indulge in some relaxation at the heated outdoor pool and hottub or in the beautiful courtyard. Those visiting for business can make use of the lobby’s computer station and wireless internet. The hotel also has a fitness center, shuttle services, and much, much more. Visit its website to learn about the amenities and dining options, as well as wedding and event packages offered at Long Island’s most beloved boutique hotel!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Garden City Hotel Best Hotel!
Garden City Hotel
45 7th St, Garden City
(516) 747-3000 – gardencityhotel.com
A legendary grand ballroom has been the site of countless opulent affairs for over 100 years at The Garden City Hotel, a beacon of opulence and old-world charm in Nassau and very accessible for city residents via the Long Island Railroad across the street and those on the Island needing a mini vacay. It’s the perfect luxury getaway for me-time or couples. It was built in 1874 to attract a high-brow clientele, Astors and Vanderbilts among them. This well-known landmark in Nassau had a multi-million dollar renovation in 2012. Highlights are Saturday afternoon High Tea, Sunday brunch and The Elizabeth Arden Red Spa. Rooms are lovely boasting custom millwork and Italian furniture, plush pillow-top mattresses, mini-refrigerators and bathrooms with French boutique amenities.
2020: Long Islanders Voted Hyatt Place Long Island/East End Best Hotel!
Hyatt Place Long Island/East End
451 E Main St, Riverhead
(631) 727-8386 – hyattplaceeastend.com
The Hyatt Place Long Island/East End offers an unique experience due to its waterfront location in North Fork; guests can sleep next to the Long Island Aquarium! Guests can also enjoy a meal with an iconic view of the Peconic River with boats filling the shores of the marina. For those looking for a beautiful place to get married they offer multiple venues on their grounds including an indoor waterfall and the Sea Star Ballroom. The hotel offers a variety of services and amenities including 24/7 dining, an outdoor and indoor pool, a fitness center and meeting rooms for business professionals.
2019: Long Islanders Voted Garden City Hotel – Garden City Best Hotel!
Garden City Hotel – Garden City
45 7th St., Garden City
(516) 747-3000 – www.gardencityhotel.com
There’s nothing like the Garden City Hotel is Long Island’s landmark of gracious hospitality and first-class service. Their elegant and historic hotel welcomes guests into spacious and luxurious guest rooms and suites, and delights with an array of new dining experiences, including Red Salt Room by David Burke. Explore all that their iconic address has to offer in the heart of picturesque Garden City. The lush, manicured grounds and recently restored event spaces of the hotel create an unmatched setting for your next meeting or social event.
2018: Long Islanders Voted East Wind Long Island – Wading River Best Hotel on Long Island
East Wind Long Island – Wading River
5720 Route 25A., Wading River. 631-929-3500. eastwindlongisland.com
East Wind Long Island – Wading River hotel, catering and spa has been named the best hotel on Long Island for 2018. East Wind offers a number of events and specials for its guests to enjoy their stay. Whether it is wedding ceremonies, the spa, the shoppes, the dining experience or the hotel itself, East Wind offers the best. Located at 5720 Route 25A., Wading River, the East Wind hotel has events going on everyday like their wine and food pairing event on Mar. 8. Take a look for yourself by calling 631-929-3500 or visit www.eastwindlongisland.com.
2017: Long Islanders Voted Hyatt Place Long Island/East End Best Hotel on Long Island
Hyatt Place Long Island/East End
451 East Main St., Riverhead. 631-208-0002. hyattplaceeastend.com
Situated on the tip of Long Island’s famed North Fork, Hyatt Place Long Island/East End offers beautiful waterfront views, all-day dining (woo-hoo!) and a complimentary shuttle service. It’s also in an ideal location, with easy access to Long Island wineries, the Hamptons, tons of family friendly activities, and many large regional companies. A 24-hour fitness facility, free Wi-Fi, 17,000-square feet of indoor and outdoor meeting space, a cocktail bar, indoor and outdoor swimming pools, a seasonal poolside bar and grill, onsite rentals (including kayaks, bikes and canoes!), a sundeck, banquet hall and event space; the amenities simply don’t stop at Hyatt Place Long Island/East End!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Oheka Castle Best Hotel on Long Island
Oheka Castle
135 W. Gate Dr., Huntington. 631-659-1400. oheka.com
Otto Kahn’s former Gold Coast estate is a mansion right out of a movie, and it has been featured on both the big and small screen, as well as the coup de grace, Taylor Swift’s music video for “Black Space.” This sprawling mansion, restored by a local developer with an investment of more than $30 million to bring America’s second-largest private home back to life, is the premier venue for extravagant weddings and other glamorous events. It features 32 luxurious guest rooms and suites with breathtaking views of the 23-acre grounds, not to mention golf, tennis, in-room spa services, and a top-notch restaurant. No wonder Long Islanders consistently vote Oheka Castle The Best!
National Winner: Ramada Rockville Centre
1000 Sunrise Highway, Rockville Centre. 516-678-1100. ramadarvc.com <br />Located in Long island’s famed Five Towns, the Ramada Rockville Centre boasts terrific amenities, such as free Wi-Fi and an absolutely scrumptious continental breakfast. Guests appreciate the modern decor and the hospitable staff, who go out of their way to make sure everyone’s needs are met. Whether you are recommending this hotel for out of towners or just looking for a night away from home, RVC Ramada is The hotel Long Islanders resoundingly declare “The Best!”
2015: Long Islanders Voted Oheka Castle Best Hotel on Long Island!
Oheka Castle
135 Westgate Dr., Huntington. 631-659-1400. oheka.com
Sleep like a king—or queen—at Otto Khan’s former Gold Coast estate. The sprawling mansion was restored by a local developer, who invested more than $30 million to bring America’s second largest private home back to life. It has since been the sight of several extravagant weddings and other glamorous events. The mansion boasts 32 luxurious guest rooms and suites with breathtaking views of the 23-acre estate. Stay at Oheka and experience some of the best golf and tennis on LI and relax with in-room massages before sitting down for a dinner unlike any other.
2014: Long Islanders Voted Oheka Castle in Huntington Best Hotel on Long Island!
1. Oheka Castle
135 Westgate Dr., Huntington. 631-659-1400. oheka.com
2. Allegria Hotel
80 W. Broadway, Long Beach. 516-889-1300. allegriahotel.com
3. Garden City Hotel
45 Seventh St., Garden City. 516-747-3000. gardencityhotel.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Allegria Hotel in Long Beach Best Hotel on Long Island!
1. Allegria Hotel
80 W. Broadway, Long Beach. 516-889-1300. www.allegriahotel.com
2. Oheka Castle
135 W. Gate Dr., Huntington. 631-659-1400. www.oheka.com
3. Gurney’s Inn Resort & Spa
290 Old Montauk Hwy., Montauk. 631-668-2345. www.gurneysinn.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Garden City Hotel in Garden City Best Hotel on Long Island!
1. Garden City Hotel
45 7th St., Garden City. 516-747-3000.www.gardencityhotel.com
2. The Inn at Fox Hollow
7755 Jericho Tpke., Woodbury. 516-224-8100. www.theinnatfoxhollow.com
3. Allegria
80 W. Broadway, Long Beach. 516-889-1300. www.allegriahotel.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted The Inn at Fox Hollow in Woodbury Best Hotel on Long Island!
1. The Inn at Fox Hollow
7755 Jericho Tpke., Woodbury. 800-291-8090. www.theinnatfoxhollow.com
2. Garden City Hotel
45 Seventh St., Garden City. 515-747-3000. www.gardencityhotel.com
3. Danfords Hotel and Marina
25 E. Broadway, Port Jefferson. 800-332-6367. www.danfords.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted The Garden City Hotel the Best Hotel on Long Island!
1. Garden City Hotel
45 E. Seventh St., Garden City. 516-747-3000 www.gardencityhotel.com
2. Danford’s Hotel & Marina
25 E. Broadway, Port Jefferson. 631-928-5200.www.danfords.com
3. The Inn at Fox Hollow
7755 Jericho Tpke., Woodbury. 516-224-8100.www.theinnatfoxhollow.com