Best French Toast on Long Island

The perfect plate of French toast is fluffy and tender on the inside and perfectly browned on the outside. It’s also one of the simplest breakfast items you can get without the hassle of waiting too long. Don’t miss out on the best French toast on Long Island!

2023: Long Islanders Voted Brownstones Coffee Best French Toast!

Brownstones Coffee
55 Merrick Rd, Amityville
(631) 608-8627 – brownstonescoffee.com

Have a sudden craving for french toast? Look no further than Brownstones Coffee, which has multiple locations in Suffolk County. Although the restaurant is known for its french toast bites, the breakfast spot also offers strawberry shortcake-stuffed french toast, cinnamon-stuffed french toast, and nutella-stuffed french toast! Don’t worry, fluffy classic french toast is also on the menu if you prefer to keep it simple. The traditional french toast and the bites are topped with fresh berries, bananas, and dusted powdered sugar. Just make sure you make a reservation or join the online waitlist before you go – it’s a super popular breakfast and brunch spot, especially on the weekends. The restaurant also serves pancakes, waffles, crepes, omelets, breakfast sandwiches, coffee, lunch specials, and more.

2022: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop Best French Toast!

CJ’s Coffee Shop
225 N Long Beach Rd, Rockville Centre
516-766-9107 – cjscoffeeshop.com

CJ’s Coffee Shop is a family restaurant with home-cooked French toast, the perfect addition to anything off of CJ’s extensive menu. Coffee or tea is included! Choose from two, three, or four slices of classic French toast with ham, bacon, sausage, or turkey sausage on the side. Do you have a sweet tooth at your table? Have them try three slices with banana, strawberry, and whipped cream. Any banana lovers? Try the banana nut French toast, grilled to perfection. At some point, everyone should try CJ’s cinnamon bun French toast, grilled from a sliced cinnamon bun! Woke up late? Breakfast is served all day, made to order, in CJ’s old-school luncheonette with a counter, stools, and memorabilia to look at.

2021: Long Islanders Voted Brownstones Coffee – Amityville Best French Toast!

Brownstones Coffee – Amityville
55 Merrick Rd, Amityville
(631) 608-8627 – brownstonescoffee.com

Have a sudden craving for french toast? Look no further then Brownstones Coffee in Amityville, best known for its french toast bites! Although the restaurant is known for its bites, the breakfast spot also offers banana nut french toast which are topped with sliced bananas, chopped peanuts, chocolate syrup and peanut butter sauce. Brownstones also offers strawberry shortcake stuffed french toast — classic french toast stuffed with creamy strawberry cream cheese and sweet strawberry sauce. The restaurant’s pecan dusted stuffed french toast has apricot cinnamon raisin cream cheese dusted with pecans! Don’t worry, fluffy classic french toast is also on the menu if you prefer to keep it simple!

2020: Long Islanders Voted Buttermilk’s Kitchen Best French Toast!

Buttermilk’s Kitchen
76 W Main St, Patchogue
(631) 654-MILK – buttermilkskitchen.com

If your answer in the whole “Pancakes vs Waffles” debate is to skip both of those and go right for french toast, Buttermilk’s Kitchen in Patchogue is the place for you. For over 25 years, Buttermilk’s Kitchen has strived to be your home away from home. In addition to their classic brioche french toast, Buttermilk’s Kitchen puts a unique spin on their french toast offerings. Their BFP french toast is topped with bananas, peanut butter and fluff. The bananas foster french toast is smothered in flambeed bananas and whipped cream. The Smores french toast? You guessed it — french toast stuffed with fluff and chocolate, topped with crushed up graham crackers, chocolate and toasted marshmallows. Don’t forget to try their “Holy Cannoli” french toast or their french toast bites!