But with countless bakeries across Long Island vying for bragging rights to the best cupcake on Long Island, only one can reign supreme. See who Long Islanders voted for.
2025: Long Islanders Voted Smallcakes – Syosset Best Cupcake!
Smallcakes – Syosset
339 Jackson Avenue, Syosset
(516) 226-1922 – smallcakesli.com
Smallcakes in Syosset creates cupcakes that are not only delicious, but miniature works of art that delight customers with rich flavors and playful designs. Each cupcake is carefully baked from scratch using top-quality ingredients to ensure a moist, flavorful cake base. From classic options like vanilla and chocolate to creative choices like salted caramel and red velvet, there’s a cupcake to satisfy every taste. The bakery’s attention to detail is evident in the vibrant frosting swirls and intricate toppings, making each treat as visually appealing as it is delicious. Whether celebrating a special event or enjoying a sweet treat, Smallcakes in Syosset guarantees a memorable experience in every bite.
2024: Long Islanders Voted Smallcakes – Syosset Best Cupcake!
Smallcakes – Syosset
339 Jackson Ave, Syosset
(516) 226-1922 – smallcakesli.com
Smallcakes in Syosset crafts cupcakes that are nothing short of miniature works of art, delighting customers with their decadent flavors and whimsical designs. Each cupcake is meticulously baked from scratch using the finest ingredients, ensuring a moist and flavorful cake base. From classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to inventive creations like salted caramel and red velvet, there’s a cupcake to satisfy every craving. But it’s not just the flavors that make Smallcakes stand out—it’s the attention to detail in their decorations. From vibrant frosting swirls to intricate toppings, every cupcake is beautifully adorned, making them as visually appealing as they are delicious. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply treating yourself to a sweet indulgence, Smallcakes in Syosset promises a delightful experience with every bite.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Smallcakes – Syosset/Seaford Best Cupcake!
Smallcakes – Syosset/Seaford
339 Jackson Ave, Syosset
(516) 226-1922 – smallcakesli.com
If you have a sweet tooth, this one’s for you. Smallcakes, of Syosset and Seaford, has earned its win for Long Island’s Best Cupcake. The family-owned and operated cupcakery and creamery is home to 13 signature cupcake flavors made fresh every morning that keep customers coming back. They’re consistently credited for the fresh, moist quality of their dessert selection. To spice things up, the shop offers daily specials from a selection of 250 unique recipes. Past specials include cupcakes with clever flavor combinations like mint cookies in cream, both rich and refreshing. To satisfy your cravings on the fly, you can download their app or order delivery through DoorDash.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Front Street Bakery Best Cupcake!
Front Street Bakery
51 Front St, Rockville Centre
(516) 766-1199 – frontstreetbakery.com
Front Street Bakery, located in Rockville Centre, is known for many things, including the Dot Cookies and the Danish Crumb Cake, but one should not leave this bakery without trying the cupcakes. Though, picking a cupcake may be a challenge because there are so many choices, including holiday themes, strawberry shortcake, Nutella, Oreo, devil dog, Boston creme, red velvet, gender reveal cupcakes, peanut butter and jelly, cannoli cream, berries and creme, raspberry chocolate mousse, lemon coconut, and much more. What makes these cupcakes special is not only the plethora of choices, but also the delicious frosting inside the cupcake, making a truly delectable cupcake inside and out.
