When it comes to sweet treats, nothing beats a beautifully crafted custom cookie. Whether for birthdays, weddings, holidays, or special events, custom-made cookies turn dessert into edible art. From intricate icing designs to personalized flavors, the best bakers create cookies that are as stunning as they are delicious. Long Island is home to talented cookie artists who bring creativity and flavor to every batch. If you’re looking for the perfect custom treats, see who our readers have voted as the Best Cookies Custom Made on Long Island.
2026: Long Islanders Voted Batter Up Bakery Best Cookies Custom Made!
Batter Up Bakery
697 N. Newbridge Road, Levittown
(516) 681-4743 – batterupbakeryny.com
Batter Up Bakery in Levittown is a beloved family‑run artisan bakery known for crafting fresh, made‑from‑scratch cookies and other baked goods using high‑quality, real ingredients like premium butter, fresh eggs, fruit, and chocolate. Their menu includes classic favorites such as chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, and rainbow sprinkle cookies, as well as custom hand‑painted cookies that can be tailored for events, celebrations, and special occasions when ordered in advance. Beyond cookies, the bakery’s offerings extend to a diverse selection of sweet treats including Italian cookies, cookie trays, and other pastries, all baked with care in their local kitchen. With custom designs available alongside their everyday favorites, Batter Up Bakery continues to be a go‑to destination for Long Islanders seeking both classic cookies and personalized, beautifully decorated sweets for any occasion.
2025: Long Islanders Voted Pixie Dust Confectionery – Holtsville Best Cookies Custom Made!
Pixie Dust Confectionery – Holtsville
69 Barretts Ave, Holtsville
(631) 827-4581 – facebook.com/100063594672446
Pixie Dust Confectionery is a charming destination for those craving a culinary experience that is truly magical. This whimsical boutique offers a delightful assortment of handcrafted sweets, each created with passion, creativity, and a touch of enchantment. From custom-made cookies and gourmet truffles to decadent cakes and playful pastries, Pixie Dust Confectionery has everything you could want to satisfy your sweet tooth. Committed to quality and craftsmanship, each treat is made using premium ingredients and traditional techniques, ensuring an unforgettable taste. Perfect for satisfying your cravings or finding a special gift for a loved one, Pixie Dust Confectionery invites visitors to explore a world of sugary delights.
2024: Long Islanders Voted Pixie Dust Confectionery – Holtsville Best Cookies Custom Made!
Pixie Dust Confectionery – Holtsville
69 Barretts Ave, Holtsville
(631) 827-4581 – facebook.com/pixiedustconfection
Pixie Dust Confectionery is a delightful haven for sweet enthusiasts seeking a magical culinary experience. This whimsical boutique offers a charming selection of handcrafted confections, each infused with creativity, passion, and a sprinkle of enchantment. From artisanal chocolates and gourmet truffles to decadent cakes and whimsical pastries, Pixie Dust Confectionery tantalizes taste buds with its diverse and imaginative offerings. With a commitment to quality and craftsmanship, every treat is lovingly made using premium ingredients and traditional techniques, ensuring a taste sensation that delights the senses. Whether indulging in a sweet craving or searching for the perfect gift, Pixie Dust Confectionery invites guests to step into a world of sugary delights and whimsical delights.
2023: Long Islanders Voted The Chocolate Duck Best Cookies Custom Made!
The Chocolate Duck
310 Main St, Farmingdale
(516) 249-0887 – chocolateduck.com
When your chocolate cravings strike, a trip to The Chocolate Duck in Farmingdale will be well worth it. The Chocolate Duck has been the largest and most beloved Long Island chocolate and cake decorating specialty shop for more than 30 years. Doubling as a bakery that sells scrumptious desserts, The Chocolate Duck offers year-round instructional chocolate, cake, and cookie decorating classes where experienced experts teach the artistry of creating custom gourmet treats. The Chocolate Duck is a premier party place for kids and adults. The venue is especially well known for their cookies, and they host an annual gingerbread house contest.