Crisp romaine, creamy dressing, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan—there’s a reason the Caesar salad is a timeless favorite. Whether enjoyed as a starter or topped with grilled chicken, shrimp, or steak for a satisfying meal, the perfect Caesar salad is all about fresh ingredients and bold flavors. Long Island is home to countless restaurants putting their own spin on this classic dish, but only one can be the best. See which spot our readers have voted as the Best Caesar Salad on Long Island.
2026: Long Islanders Voted Foster Best Caesar Salad!
Foster
39 Roslyn Ave, Sea Cliff
(516) 759-0100 – fosterrestaurant.com
Foster Restaurant in Sea Cliff features a signature Charred Broccolini Caesar on its menu, a creative twist on the classic Caesar salad that pairs crisp greens with sourdough crostini and grilled lemon for added flavor and texture. This salad reflects Foster’s approach of putting a thoughtful, seasonal spin on familiar favorites as part of its locally inspired, ever‑evolving menu of American fare crafted from scratch. Located in the heart of Sea Cliff, the restaurant underscores its commitment to fresh ingredients and culinary innovation, and salads like the Charred Broccolini Caesar are available alongside other starter and entrée options that highlight seasonal produce and bold flavors.
2025: Long Islanders Voted Joe’s Pizza & Pasta Best Caesar Salad!
Joe’s Pizza & Pasta
346 Union Avenue, Holbrook
(631) 981-3029 – joespizzany.com
The Caesar salad craze sweeping social media has similarly taken Long Island by storm, with many eateries all over the region offering unique spins on the classic dish. But if you’re craving a simple, standard Caesar salad, Joe’s Pizza is the place to go. Joe’s has proudly served the Long Island community for nearly 50 years, serving up the highest quality Italian fare alongside a wide variety of to-go style slices. Although Joe’s is famous for its sumptuous steamed mussels and delectable chicken wings, the Caesar salad starter can’t be missed. Crisp shreds of romaine lettuce are lightly tossed with the restaurant’s homemade Caesar dressing before getting topped off with a sprinkling of seasoned croutons. ¡Buon appetito!