Sweet, smoky, tangy, or spicy—great BBQ sauce is all about bold flavor. Whether it’s slathered on ribs, brushed over grilled chicken, or used as a dipping sauce, the best BBQ sauce strikes the perfect balance of richness and zest. Long Island is home to pitmasters and chefs who craft mouthwatering sauces that take barbecue to the next level. If you’re looking for the perfect blend of flavors to elevate your next meal, see which spot our readers have voted as the Best BBQ Sauce on Long Island.
2026: Long Islanders Voted Double Barrel BBQ LI Best BBQ Sauce!
Double Barrel BBQ LI
P.O. Box 743, Middle Island
doublebarrelbbqlongisland.com
Double Barrel BBQ LI crafts artisan BBQ sauces on Long Island that bring bold, smoky, and inventive flavor to grilling and backyard barbecues. Their lineup includes creative varieties like Maple Bacon Bourbon, which blends sweet maple syrup with savory bacon notes and aged bourbon for depth and warmth, perfect for ribs, chicken, or grilled veggies. Another favorite, Hot Honey, pairs smooth honey sweetness with a spicy kick from chili peppers, giving dishes a lively sweet‑heat balance that enhances everything from wings to pulled pork. These sauces are made to elevate classic barbecue fare with memorable flavor profiles that appeal to grill masters and food lovers alike. In addition to sauces, Double Barrel also offers dry rubs and seasonal recipe ideas that help home cooks experiment with new tastes and textures in their outdoor cooking.
2025: Long Islanders Voted Double Barrel BBQ LI Best BBQ Sauce!
Double Barrel BBQ LI
doublebarrelbbqlongisland.com
You can replicate the most mouth-watering BBQ dishes you see on social media once you source your BBQ sauce from Double Barrel BBQ LI. The artisan-crafted barbecue sauce brand brings scrumptious decadence that foodies across the Island seek at Double Barrel BBQ LI. Seasoned grillers choose their sauce to elevate a hearty barbecue meal to sensation status among guests and family. Go in and sink your teeth into the region’s best nod to the spicy, savory, sweet flavors of the Southwest, and try this exemplary accompaniment at your next barbecue. Then come away with your stock of fine barbecue sauce options including Maple Bacon Bourbon, Hot Honey, and White Truffle Roasted Garlic,