Long Island is so car-centric that there is little doubt that at some point in your driving life that you will need to replace an auto part. Luckily, we have plenty of auto parts stores to accommodate your auto part needs. Here are the best on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted Mars Auto Parts – Bay Shore Best Auto Parts Store!
Mars Auto Parts – Bay Shore
108 E Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 665-0890 – marsauto.net
Established in 1946 by war veterans Harry Stein and Walter Sobel in Freeport, Mars Auto Parts expanded to Bay Shore in 1948. While the Freeport store eventually closed, the Bay Shore location flourished, evolving into a cherished family business. Generations of Sobels now operate the store, embodying a deep passion for automotive excellence. Mars caters to a diverse clientele, supplying parts to car owners, repair shops, farmers, fishermen, dock builders, collectors, and truck drivers. The shop’s versatility extends to custom services, including cutting drums, rotors, and flywheels, as well as crafting hydraulic hoses, battery cables, and heavy-duty tachometer cables. With a vast repository of knowledge spanning a century, Mars Auto Parts ensures that if an auto part is elusive on Earth, it can be found on Mars.
2024: Long Island Voted Parts Authority Best Auto Parts Store! (National)
Parts Authority
Multiple Locations
(516) 678-3900 – partsauthority.com
Parts Authority offers a comprehensive range of automotive products and accessories to customers on Long Island. With a commitment to excellence and a vast inventory, Parts Authority provides a one-stop solution for professional mechanics, auto enthusiasts, and DIYers alike. Their extensive selection includes quality replacement parts, tools, and accessories from leading brands, ensuring reliability and performance. The knowledgeable and friendly staff at Parts Authority assists customers in finding the right components for their vehicles, promoting a seamless shopping experience. Whether it’s engine components, brakes, or electrical parts, Parts Authority is recognized for its reliability, expertise, and dedication to meeting the diverse automotive needs of the community.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Long Island Foreign Auto Parts Best Auto Parts Store! (Tie)
Long Island Foreign Auto Parts
290 Willis Ave, Mineola
(516) 625-0940 – longislandforeignauto.com
When you’re shopping around for your next set of auto parts, you want to be sure that you’re choosing the best auto parts store on Long Island. But how do you know which one to choose? The question shouldn’t be why should I buy my auto parts from Long Island Foreign Auto Parts, but rather why shouldn’t I? Since opening in 1993, Long Island Foreign Auto Parts has been offering a wide selection of quality automotive parts and car accessories at affordable prices, with options to ship across the U.S., so you don’t have to worry about finding those hard-to-find auto parts anywhere else. They’ll get your motor running in no time!
2023: Long Islanders Voted Parts Authority Best Auto Parts Store! (Tie)
Parts Authority
Multiple Locations
partsauthority.com
Is your car making a strange noise? Does it turn right when you turn the wheel left? It might be time to take it to the Parts Authority! With over 45 years of parts experience and professional problem solvers that can get the job done, Parts Authority can fix any issue your vehicle is giving you. They offer fast delivery, same-day shipping, national warranty programs and extraordinary customer service to all who walk through their doors. If you need a car service you can trust with your sweet ride, try Parts Authority. You won’t be disappointed.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Long Island Foreign Auto Parts Best Auto Parts Store!
Tuning Works
111-B Ralph Ave, Copiague
516-625-0940 – longislandforeignauto.com
When you’re shopping around for your next set of auto parts, you want to be sure that you’re choosing the best auto parts store on Long Island. But how do you know which one to choose? The question shouldn’t be why should I buy my auto parts from Long Island Foreign Auto Parts, but rather why shouldn’t I? Since opening in 1993, Long Island Foreign Auto Parts has been offering a wide selection of quality automotive parts and car accessories at affordable prices, with options to ship across the U.S., so you don’t have to worry about finding those hard-to-find auto parts anywhere else. They’ll get your motor running in no time!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Tuning Works Best Auto Parts Store!
Tuning Works
111-B Ralph Ave, Copiague
(631) 608-9005 – tuning-works.com
Buying replacement car parts can be a daunting (not to mention expensive) task. At Tuning Works, it doesn’t have to be. Started by three car enthusiasts, Tuning Works has the tools it needs to not only provide parts to keep your car maintained, but also to modify it into the car of your dreams. Tuning Works doesn’t cut corners — it prides itself on having top-notch service and honest, practical advice for customers and is driven by pure passion for speed, stance, and style. After getting your car back from Tuning Works, you’ll see why its clients are proud to hang its window banners on their cars!
2020: Long Islanders Voted Parts Authority – Multiple Locations Best Auto Parts Store! (Tie)
Parts Authority
Multiple Locations
partsauthority.com
Is your car making a strange noise? Does it turn right when you turn the wheel left? It might be time to take it to the Parts Authority! With over 45 years of parts experience and professional problem solvers that can get the job done, Parts Authority can fix any issue your vehicle is giving you. They offer fast delivery, same-day shipping, national warranty programs and extraordinary customer service to all who walk through their doors. If you need a car service you can trust with your sweet ride, try Parts Authority. You won’t be disappointed.
2020: Long Islanders Voted Tuning Works Best Auto Parts Store! (Tie)
Tuning Works
111-B Ralph Ave, Copiague
(631) 608-9005 – tuning-works.com
Buying replacement car parts can be a daunting (not to mention expensive) task. At Tuning Works, it doesn’t have to be. Started by three car enthusiasts, Tuning Works has the tools they need to not only provide parts to keep your car maintained, but also to modify it into the car of your dreams. At Tuning Works, they don’t cut corners — they pride themselves on having top-notch service and honest, practical advice for their customers and are driven by pure passion for speed, stance, and style. After getting your car back from Tuning Works, you’ll see why their customers are proud to hang their window banners on their cars!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Broadway Auto Parts Best Auto Parts Store!
Broadway Auto Parts
48 Broadway, Greenlawn
(631) 261-3360
When it comes to finding replacement parts for your vehicle, nothing beats the attention and expertise that you get at a local mom and pop shop. And when it comes to local mom and pop auto parts stores, Broadway Auto Parts leaves the competition in the dust. Your car or truck will surely agree after one visit! No wonder why Long Islanders voted Broadway Auto Parts the Best Auto Parts Store on Long Island!
Parts Authority (National Winner)
Multiple Locations
partsauthority.com
Your car has a lot of parts. So does every location of Parts Authority, one of the largest distributors of car and truck parts in the United States. Standard replacement parts for most domestic and imported cars and trucks are easy to find, those name-brands that you know and trust. But Parts Authority also carries many OE (original equipment) and hard-to-find items. Thanks to their vast inventory—not to mention their knowledgeable sales staff—chances are Parts Authority can find the exact part that needs replacing in your vehicle. With numerous locations around Long Island, you won’t have to go far to get your car running like new.
2018: Long Islanders Voted Parts Authority Best Auto Parts Store on Long Island
Parts Authority
Multiple Locations
www.partsauthority.com/index.php
Your car has a lot of parts. So does every location of Parts Authority, one of the largest distributors of car and truck parts in the United States. Standard replacement parts for most domestic and imported cars and trucks are easy to find, those name-brands that you know and trust. But Parts Authority also carries many OE (original equipment) and hard-to-find items. Thanks to their vast inventory—not to mention their knowledgeable sales staff—chances are Parts Authority can find the exact part that needs replacing in your vehicle. With numerous locations around Long Island, you won’t have to go far to get your car running like new.
2017: Long Islanders Voted Broadway Auto Parts Best Auto Parts Store on Long Island
Broadway Auto Parts
48 Broadway, Greenlawn. 631-261-3360.
When it comes to finding replacement parts for your vehicle, nothing beats the attention and expertise that you get at a local mom and pop shop. And when it comes to local mom and pop auto parts stores, Broadway Auto Parts leaves the competition in the dust. Your car or truck will surely agree after one visit! No wonder why Long Islanders voted Broadway Auto Parts the Best Auto Parts Store on Long Island!
National Winner: AutoZone
Multiple Locations. 800-288-6966. autozone.com
Not only is AutoZone the go-to spot nationally for consumers interested in a do-it-yourself fix, but it’s also where Long Islanders choose to spend their well-earned money when they’re in need of replacement parts to get their beloved vehicle up and running again. AutoZone carries everything your car needs: brake pads, batteries, spark plugs, alternator, headlights, engine oil, and much, much more. Not the most mechanically gifted person? No worries, AutoZone’s knowledgeable staff will lead you on the right path. As their slogan goes: “Get in the zone!”
2016: Long Islanders Voted Family Auto Parts Best Auto Parts Store on Long Island
Family Auto Parts
3205 Horseblock Rd., Medford. 631-654-0088. advertel.com/partsplus/family/
With more than three decades of experience serving central Long Island competitive pricing, a wide variety of high-quality products and well-known brand names, Family Auto Parts is well worth the drive. These guys prove that nothing beats a local, family-run shop, where the staff treats you like more than just a number!
National Winner: Advanced Auto Parts
Multiple Locations. advanceautoparts.com
Whether your car needs something as simple as a new accessory and detail, or parts critical to keeping the motor in working order, such as a new alternator, this is the one-stop shop for all its automotive needs. Taking back the Best of Long Island winner’s trophy in the national auto parts store category for the first time since 2014 is this renowned chain, with more than a dozen locations across Nassau and Suffolk counties. Come see why their slogan is “We’re ready in advance!”
2015: Long Islanders Voted ABC Automobile Parts, Inc. in Syosset Best Auto Parts Store on Long Island!
ABC Automobile Parts, Inc.
231 Robbins Ln., Syosset. 516-942-7265.
ABC Automobile Parts in Syosset has risen above the rest of the competition by earning the respect and adulation of its customers, many who rely on their courteous and professional staff to point them in the right direction when searching for replacement parts. It’s not easy to earn the title of “Best,” especially in this competitive category, but ABC Automobile Parts clearly has become a trusted source for Long Island’s replacement parts and needs, as this coveted honor is testament!
National Winner. Auto Zone
Multiple Locations. 631-425-9360. autozone.com
Not only is AutoZone the go-to spot nationally for consumers interested in a do-it-yourself fix, but it’s also where Long Islanders choose to spend their well-earned money when they’re in need of replacement parts to get their vehicle up and running again. AutoZone carries everything your car might need: brake pads, batteries, spark plugs, alternators, headlights, engine oil, and more. Not the most mechanically gifted person? No worries, AutoZone’s knowledgeable staff will lead point you on the right direction. As the slogan goes: “Get in the zone!”
2014: Long Islanders Voted Farmingdale Auto Parts in Farmingdale Best Auto Parts Store on Long Island!
1. Farmingdale Auto Parts
848 Main St., Farmingdale. 516-420-9060.
2. Parts Authority
Multiple Locations. partsauthority.com
3. Family Auto Parts
3205 Horseblock Rd., Medford. 631-654-0088.
NATIONAL
Advance Auto Parts
Multiple Locations. 516-822-4200. advanceautoparts.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Farmingdale Auto Parts in Farmingdale Best Auto Parts Store on Long Island!
1. Farmingdale Auto Parts
848 Main St., Farmingdale. 516-420-9060
2. Swift II Auto Restyling
64 Newtown Plaza, Plainview. 516-777-1177
3. Superior Auto Restyling
81 Urban Ave., Westbury. 516-997-8787. www.superiorautorestyling.com
NATIONAL
Auto Zone
Multiple Locations. www.autozone.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Farmingdale Auto Parts in Farmingdale Best Auto Parts Store on Long Island!
1. Farmingdale Auto Parts
848 Main St., Farmingdale. 516-420-9060.
2. Any Parts Auto Store
35 Bay Shore Rd., Bay Shore. 631-667-1177. www.autoanything.com
3. Mars Auto Parts
108 E Main St., Bay Shore. 631-665-0890. www.marsauto.net
NATIONAL
Pep Boys
Multiple locations. www.pepboys.com
