Restaurants that don’t have a specific kind of cuisine are great because they satisfy the tastebuds of everyone who’s going out to eat there. And that’s pretty much what American and continental food is. Burgers, sandwiches, pastas and more often make up such a menu, and there are plenty of places on Long Island that have just that. If this is the kind of food you crave, then look no further than the Best American/Continental Restaurant on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted 317 Main Street Best American/Continental Restaurant!
317 Main Street
317 Main Street, Farmingdale
(516) 512-5317 – 317mainstreet.com
317 Main Street is a gastronomic haven celebrated for its inventive and diverse menu, showcasing a fusion of American and continental flavors. The chefs at 317 Main Street expertly craft each dish using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring a dining experience that delights the palate. From savory appetizers to decadent entrees, the restaurant offers a symphony of flavors that caters to diverse tastes. The warm and inviting ambiance complements the culinary journey, making 317 Main Street a sought-after destination for intimate dinners, celebrations, and gourmet enthusiasts alike, setting a standard for exceptional American and continental cuisine in the heart on Long Island!
2023: Long Islanders Voted J & R’s Steakhouse Best American/Continental Restaurant!
J & R’s Steakhouse
2347 Route 112, Medford
(631) 475-3839 – jandrssteakhouse.com
J & R’s Steakhouse of Islip is a family-owned eatery that has been serving up great steaks and burgers for almost a decade. Best known for its marinated steaks and premium burgers, J & R’s Steakhouse also offers combos, daily deals, seafood, and other delicious meals for affordable prices. The restaurant gives back to the veterans community via its veterans buy-one-entree, get-one-free promotion that runs on Mondays and Tuesdays; plus, kids eat for free on Sundays! The J & R’s lounge has a warm and inviting atmosphere, and the waitstaff is professional and friendly. If you’re looking for a quick bite and a cold beer, there is a large selection on tap and in bottles and the very best cocktails and spirits.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Mercato Restaurant Best American/Continental Restaurant!
Mercato Restaurant
4958 Merrick Rd, Massapequa Park
(516) 308-3582
Mercato has made a name for itself in the Long Island dining scene. There are so many American/Continental-style restaurants in the region – so why Mercato? Owners Brian and Keleigh, Executive Chef Matt, and the Mercato staff have made the eatery all about providing guests with a great dining experience. With both Italian and American influences, Long Islanders know that Mercato’s savory dishes, such as flatbreads, burgers, pastas, and delicious entrees, will pair stupendously with wines, cocktails, or other alcoholic beverages. Plus, the restaurant offers “mercato,” or “market”-fresh salads and uses fresh, local ingredients for all their dishes. Mercato also offers daily specials, so check the website and plan to eat out at the restaurant everyone’s talking about!
2021: Long Islanders Voted City Cellar Wine Bar & Grill Best American/Continental Restaurant!
City Cellar Wine Bar & Grill
1080 Corporate Dr, Westbury
(516) 693-5400 – citycellarny.com
City Cellar Wine Bar & Grill is an upscale, modern American restaurant that offers brunch, lunch and dinner as well as a wide selection of drinks. If you are looking for a night out with your significant other or a girl’s night, this place has you covered with its relaxed and upscale environment. Both the brunch and lunch menus include individual meals as well as boards for the tables. Each of these boards feed about 2-3 people and are a great option if your group is looking to try multiple dishes at once. Pair one of these boards with a side and wine from their extensive list for a meal to remember!
2020: Long Islanders Voted Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge Best American/Continental Restaurant!
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
4 Patchogue Dr, Rocky Point
(631) 744-4100 – spiroslounge.com
Looking for some luscious American cuisine that will make your mouth water with one glance? Stroll on over to Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge and order some classic fancy American meals to enjoy on a date, with friends or family! Spiro’s serves a wide variety of meals and entrees, and a even broader selection of cocktails and mixed drinks. Spiro’s only serves the best drinks and food, making it an ideal spot for a romantic evening with someone special or a relaxed night out with friends. Let go of the stress and go have some fun at Spiro’s!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge Best American/Continental Restaurant!
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
4 Patchogue Dr., Rocky Point
(631) 744-4100 – www.spiroslounge.com
At Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge in Rocky Point, you can treat yourself to a hearty meal of steak and potatoes. Interested in eating out over the weekend? Carry-out is also always available for those who prefer to enjoy this restaurant’s cooking from the comfort of their own home. This dining establishment is located near hassle-free parking options. Store your bike at a nearby rack and enjoy a bite to eat at Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge. Visa, MasterCard, Discover, and American Express are all accepted. Everyone deserves to treat themselves every once in a while, so head on over to Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge and indulge!
2018: Long Islanders Voted Shandon Court Best American/Continental Restaurant on Long Island
Shandon Court
115 E.Main Street
East Islip, NY 11730
(631) 581-5678. shandoncourt.com
Not your typical Irish pub by any means, Shandon Court is like royalty when it comes to offering traditional American and Continental cuisine that is anything but ordinary. From sizzling steaks to scrumptious chicken dishes and fresh seafood, the kitchen at Shandon Court knows how to exceed expectations. Every meal is served to perfection in a great setting on the South Shore that pleases the eye as the food satisfies the stomach and restores the soul. It’s fun place to enjoy a family feast.
2017: Long Islanders Voted Shandon Court Best American/Continental Restaurant on Long Island
Shandon Court
115 E. Main St., East Islip. 631-581-5678. shandoncourt.com
Not your typical Irish pub by any means, Shandon Court is like royalty when it comes to offering traditional American and Continental cuisine that is anything but ordinary. From sizzling steaks to scrumptious chicken dishes and fresh seafood, the kitchen at Shandon Court knows how to exceed expectations. Every meal is served to perfection in a great setting on the South Shore that pleases the eye as the food satisfies the stomach and restores the soul. It’s fun place to enjoy a family feast.
2016: Long Islanders Voted Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge Best American/Continental Restaurant on Long Island
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
4 Patchogue Dr., Rocky Point. 631-744-4100. spiroslounge.com
A multiple winner across several categories, this phenomenal restaurant offers exceptional dishes ranging from top-notch aged steaks, flavorful chicken and succulent seafood to nearly every appetizer and dessert imaginable. Owner / Chef Spiro Karachopan blends these outstanding meals with impeccable service, a combination no doubt responsible for taking Spiro’s to the top of so many different categories across this prestigious list!
Happy Hour 7 Days a Week, Twice a Day
- Sunday to Thursday, 2-6pm
- Friday & Saturday, 2-5pm
- and Every Night, 9-12pm
2015: Long Islanders Voted Palmer’s American Grille Best American / Continental Restaurant on Long Island!
Palmer’s American Grille
123 Fulton St., Farmingdale. 516-420-0609. palmersamericangrille.com
At Palmer’s American Grille, the freshness of the food is as important as the elegant ambiance and impeccable service. The menu boasts such delectable items as baby artichoke hearts, Beef Wellington, rack of New Zealand lamb, hazelnut encrusted Chilean sea bass and fresh farm vegetables to delight your senses and satisfy any palate.
2014: Long Islanders Voted Vitae Restaurant & Wine Bar in Huntington Best American/Continental Restaurant on Long island!
1. Palmer’s American Grille
123 Fulton St., Farmingdale. 516-420-0609. palmersamericangrille.com
2. Teller’s American Chop House
605 Main St., Islip. 631-277-7070. tellerschophouse.com
3. Argyle Grill and Tavern
90 Deer Park Ave., Babylon. 631-321-4900. theargylegrill.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Vitae Restaurant & Wine Bar in Huntington Best American/Continental Restaurant on Long Island!
1. Vitae Restaurant & Wine Bar
54 New St., Huntington. 631-385-1919. www.vitaeli.com
2. George Martin’s Grillfire
65 N. Park Ave., Rockville Centre. 516-678-7272. www.georgemartintheoriginal.com
3. Shandon Court
115 E. Main St., East Islip. 631-581-5678. www.shandoncourt.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Shandon Court in East Islip Best American/Continental Restaurant on Long Island!
1. Shandon Court
115 E. Main St., East Islip. 631-581-5678. www.shandoncourt.com
2. Argyle Grill and Tavern
90 Deer Park Ave., Babylon. 631-321-4900. www.theargylegrill.com
3. Hemingway’s
1885 Wantagh Ave., Wantagh. 516-781-2700. www.hemingwaysgrill.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Shandon Court in East Islip Best American/Continental on Long Island!
1. Shandon Court
115 East Main St., East Islip. 631-581-5678. www.shandoncourt.com
2. Hemingway’s American Bar & Grill
1885 Wantagh Ave., Wantagh. 516-781-2700. www.hemingwaysgrill.com
3. Tellers Chophouse
605 Main St., Islip. 631-277-7070. www.tellerschophouse.com
2010: Long Islanders Have Voted Argyle Grill & Tavern In Babylon The Best American/Continental Restaurant on Long Island!
1. Argyle Grill & Tavern
90 Deer Park Ave., Babylon. 631-321-4900. www.theargylegrill.com
2. Tellers Restaurant
605 Main St., Islip. 631-277-7070. www.tellerschophouse.com
3. Milk & Sugar Cafe
49 W. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-969-4430. www.milkandsugarcafe.com
